To: Gordon A. Langston who wrote (23795 ) 10/30/1998 11:44:00 AM From: Rob S. Respond to of 164684
Covey said (from memory, not notes) that Amazon has seen about 63% of sales come from repeat customers and that increases in expenditures are due primarily to expansion in Europe and domestic facilities and personnel. The story is that these increases will eventually flatten out while sales growth continues. IF margins remain near current levels or improve, then the company should eventually make money. If sales grow near the same pace and turn marginally profitable, then the earnings will be substantial. If margins come under significant pressure, then the "story" of the business plan is blasted. What analysts found particularly encouraging in the lst qtr and cc was the success Amazon had with music. That supports the theory that Amazon is building "brand" loyalty that can be easily transferred to additional product areas. The growth in sales due to existing customers is also supportive of the idea that they are building brand loyalty. The proposition is that while it is expensive to acquire new customers, as the existing base of customers becomes a larger part of overall sales and as the company continues to achieve a "critical mass" of reach, then the costs of doing business will drop dramatically. It now costs something like $35 to gain a new customer and it takes several months for that initial investment to pay off. What clouds the issue is that the company does not give out details on customer retention or granularity in what customers are buying relative to how long they have been a customer. Are new book (and now music) customers loading up on books during their initial months as an on-line buyer? Do sales then drop off? Or are customers buying at a sustained pace? What percentage of customers are returning month after month rather than leaving after some period of time? An analysis of these issues would provide a more thorough understanding of the the probability for long-term success of the "grand plan". Bezos and Covey argue that this would provide too much detail of their business to competitors so that they could devise strategies to target Amazon's customers or new customers more effectively. That's a reasonable concern. As much as I like to poke wholes in the theory of fat profits sometime in the distant future, I like a lot of things about Amazon. Bezos has strongly emphasized careful attention to supplying customers with a good browsing and purchasing experience. This close attention to detail, as opposed to an emphasis of tacking on features that crash or bog down the system, wins customer loyalty. Amazon listens to and delivers what customers want most but don't go overboard with the frills that have proven to be problems for others - even Microsoft has been guilty of faulty site execution, faulty java applets, and other lack of attention to details and failure to hold to conformity at their numerous sites. OK, Amazon.com IS a premier e-tailer and has been careful to stay focused on the customer and on the running of their Internet and back-office systems. Amazon has continued to grow despite the early efforts of competition. And amazon has shown that they can successfully branch out into similar product areas and have achieved a significant degree of "stickiness" to their customer base. But what is out of sink with this reality is that the stock price currently reflects a belief that the end game will be large sales at high margin levels. Everyone knows that these are the "Camelot" days of Internet growth. The business cycle is one of extremely rapid expansion in which price pressure is still not very important. The contest at this stage is to attract customers not to compete primarily on price and the market is far from reaching an absorption stage due to overall growth. But many analysts models project profits starting in about three years. I believe that will be just when the business environment starts to shift more to holding onto customers rather than primarily on attracting them. As trade journals (Internet Week) and studies (IBM Research) have pointed out, the number one interest among Internet shoppers is low price. As new markets mature past the "introduction phase", price ALWAYS becomes more important. This is particularly true for commodity products. While commodity products are ideal for early development of e-commerce, they will become low margin business as the Internet is increasingly accepted. Can Amazon.com become the "Nordstrom" of e-tailers? Maybe so. But what should investors expect for margins and earnings? The current price level and analysts target prices are highly speculative. They are reasonable only if high margins can be achieved while maintaining sales growth. I think that Amazon will be established as one of the premier Internet e-tailers. I don't think that the profits they will achieve will be anywhere close to justifying the current stock price. Even if they were, the stock is now bid up to the level it should be in two years. There is little room for disappointment: if sales don't continue to grow at a healthy pace or margins come under increased price pressure, then the "story" of the stock falls apart.