To: Melissa McAuliffe who wrote (874 ) 11/11/1998 1:06:00 PM From: Mohan Marette Respond to of 2339
ERP-Hell on Earth. (from computerworld)- I see money in SCM. Melissa and all: Just ran in to this article. ============================================= Life without users Maryfran JohnsonLife without users would be so peaceful. That has to be what some ERP vendors are secretly thinking these days. Why? Because as more enterprise resource planning software goes live across our great land, the unpleasant truth is leaking out. Those wildly popular, tightly integrated business software systems aren't only complex and costly to install — they can be hell on earth to actually use. Once they slip from the highly trained hands of the experts and into the clumsy grasp of ordinary people such as business managers, salespeople or loading-dock workers, everybody gets a good slap of reality. ERP buyers can get blindsided by the amount of user training required. After the system goes live, calls to the help desk skyrocket. Worker productivity may take a powder. Your whole company is likely to be in an uproar for months as you force-fit your business processes into a new mold. Our front-page story in last week's issue detailing Hydro Agri North America's experience ["ERP user interfaces drive workers nuts"] was only the latest real-world example of how steep the downside of ERP packages such as SAP's R/3 can really be. The chore of navigating through six R/3 screens to enter data was slowing workers down and actually threatening the quality of customer service at the company's fertilizer stores in Canada. Similar scenarios have played out at companies with new installations of ERP applications from PeopleSoft, Baan, Oracle, J.D. Edwards and others. This is the politically incorrect part of the ERP Magical Mystery Tour — the part that vendors wish our readers would quit complaining about and Computerworld would quit writing about. Let's not dwell on those pesky ease-of-use issues. Let's focus on the shimmering promise of incredible business benefits, shall we? Well, no thanks. We'll keep writing about both sides of ERP and about the business clash of two contradictory trends. Users are clamoring for simplicity and ease of use. Vendors are delivering complexity and steeper learning curves. Somebody's got to keep pushing for some hard-core honesty from both sides. We cheerfully volunteer. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------