To: William Epstein who wrote (6223 ) 11/5/1998 9:48:00 AM From: Robert Douglas Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 7841
William, you wrote:My reference to analysts is really a question. Do analysts have to have confirmations before they rec. or do they help create price movements by doing it? If they all do it at the same time then all they do is confirm each other. Does the king have no clothes? William, the analyst community is really a very inbred bunch. At least their offspring all look pretty much the same. <g> That is to say, their recommendations tend to follow one another. If a dozen analysts follow a particular stock, you can be assured that they all know what the others are saying. Many times they know each other personally, having met at company visits. It is no coincidence therefore, that many times you will see several analysts move their opinions on the same day. There is a feeling of security in being able to say to your boss, “Yeah, I blew it on Megalotron, but Fogbottom over at Merrill Lynch blew it too.” Remember for most of these guys and gals the top priority is keeping their job and landing on the Institutional Investor all-star list. Big bonus! Yesterday I posted a wonderful quote from one of the century's great economists, John Maynard Keynes. The last part is worth repeating.“…worldly wisdom teaches that it is better for reputation to fail conventionally than to succeed unconventionally.” Since reputation is of primary importance to this gang, there is little chance that they will risk this reputation by standing alone and run the possibility of being wrong. Being wrong in a crowd, of course, is acceptable, if not encouraged. I didn't hide my disdain very well did I? In that case let me say that I find more original thinking on the sports page than in a stack of analyst reports. -Robert