To: Kerm Yerman who wrote (13951 ) 12/1/1998 9:43:00 AM From: Kerm Yerman Respond to of 15196
IN THE NEWS / Oil patch agonizes over crude price The Globe & Mail How low can it go? That's the question of the week in the oil patch, as crude oil prices continue to set new lows. Adjusted for inflation, prices are the lowest they have been since the mid-1970s, and the damage to balance sheets continues to escalate. Some analysts see little sign of light at the end of the tunnel, and say oil could hit single digits. The latest blow to confidence was the meeting of OPEC representatives last week, a pathetically ineffectual get-together. Despite a history of discord and incompetence in the group, industry experts had hoped that the meeting might lead to further production cutbacks. By Thursday, those hopes were dashed, and the U.S. stock market had the whole Thanksgiving holiday weekend to dwell on where prices go from here. By the market's close yesterday, the crude oil futures contract for January delivery had fallen to $11.22 (U.S.) on the New York Mercantile Exchange. At one point during the day it was as low as $10.82 a barrel -- lower than it has been since 1986, even without accounting for inflation. As recently as last March, the January contract was at $18. At their meeting, OPEC leaders agreed to extend the production cutbacks of 2.6 million barrels a day that they imposed earlier this year, but most observers had already concluded that this would not be enough to prop up the declining price of crude. Adding to the skepticism was the fact that Iraq's oil-for-food deal with the United Nations (which allows it to get around international sanctions and sell oil) was also extended recently. Part of the pessimism that inevitably surrounds these OPEC meetings has to do with the notorious leakiness of the organization's cutbacks. Because the group is made up of countries that compete with each other for oil revenue, and since several have economies that rely on that revenue for a majority of their gross domestic product, cheating is endemic. The current speculation is that both Venezuela -- whose government is under pressure to fix the economy before elections in December -- and Iran are cheating. In the past, so-called "swing" producer Saudi Arabia has picked up the slack, but it has said it will not do so this time. Kuwaiti oil minister Sheik Saud al-Sabah told Reuters Saturday that he feared prices could plunge as low as $5 a barrel unless more cuts are made. According to a U.S. research firm specializing in oil economics, oil prices in the post-Second-World-War era have averaged $19.27 a barrel (in 1996 dollars). But the median price was $15.27, meaning that 50 per cent of the time oil prices have been above that level and 50 per cent of the time they have been below it. The median price since 1869 is $14.91. The Centre for Global Energy Studies predicts that slower growth in demand for oil and increasing production will keep prices low for the next decade or more. Sheik Ahmed Yamani, who was Saudi Arabia's oil minister from 1962 to 1986 and is now chairman of CGES, said he expects demand growth will be weaker during the next 10 years than it has been for the past decade -- while "OPEC's ability to produce oil, on the other hand, will continue to rise." The U.S. Energy Information Administration, which forecasts energy prices, says it expects the U.S. import price for crude next year to average $13.65. The EIA says 1998 will be the first year since 1990 that world demand has grown by less than one million barrels a day. Some market contrarians, of course, are already thinking that if this is the darkest moment in the oil business in 25 years or more, then now is the time to start buying oil stocks. But seasoned players warn that the market for oil companies hasn't sunk as low as it needs to before it can rebound -- a point that some analysts refer to as "capitulation." Chuck Charlton, an investment banker in Calgary with a macroeconomic view of the markets, says he has been skeptical about oil prices since last fall, shortly before they started to plummet from the $22 level. Mr. Charlton says he didn't buy the conventional wisdom that Asian growth would continue to fuel strong demand for oil for the foreseeable future. Mr. Charlton is one of those who believes that the market hasn't yet achieved capitulation, and several market players attending a recent FirstEnergy open house agreed. "It's not there yet -- but it's getting close," said one. The Toronto Stock Exchange's oil and gas subindex closed yesterday at 4,804, up from a low 4,352 in September but still down more than 40 per cent from a high of about 8,000 set in October, 1997. When the market begins to feel optimistic about oil again is the billion-dollar question. Some industry watchers say it could be some time before the price begins to pick up, given growing production and lagging demand from Asia. The only bright spot is that at current prices there is a lot of high-cost production in the world that will have to be shut down, and that in turn will help prop up the commodity price somewhat.