SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Biotech / Medical : XOMA. Bull or Bear? -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Slugger who wrote (8320)1/16/1999 11:43:00 PM
From: aknahow  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 17367
 
No, that is not the case. If one goes back to the fact that this is a rare disease it would have taken years and years to get a sufficient number of accruals to become a statistically significant trial. During those years many kids would die.

It was a sound decision on the part of all the FDA the DSMB and XOMA to arrive at a compromise method which would provide convincing data for the medical profession, scientist and officials at the FDA. It evidently became clear that the quickest way to get there was to allow the trial to be halted when ??X?? number of deaths occurred.

But things changed as the U.K. was added. Yes this meant now it might have been possible to do a trial based on accrruals. Yes the U.K. resulted in more deaths in total quicker than expected. But then quicker diagnosis in the U.K. might have lowered deaths and then if BPI is effective even fewer might have occurred. So the U.K. is what is making it posssible to halt the trial sooner. And with 20/20 vision knowing how many the subjects the U>K. would add a different trial design might have been possible. But does one risk stopping the trial before the mandatory number of deaths have occurred, when the data is blinded to management? If you guess wrong, and stopping is not acceptable, then your drug never gets to the kids. In this situation of a rare disease I think everything was done by all to find the quickest way to end this trial.

Disclaimer. All the above is based upon only one fact, "total deaths" Everything else is pure conjecture, none if may be true some of it may be false. I have no knowledge of how the trial was designed nor any knowledge of how the FDA made its' decisions on this trial.

I still believe the FDA should only be in the business of determining safety, but at the time the trial was designed I think what I speculate was done was a great decision, and one that was designed to save lives.




To: Slugger who wrote (8320)1/17/1999 1:22:00 AM
From: aknahow  Respond to of 17367
 
From the U.K.:

Two teenagers die in outbreak of
meningococcal disease in Rotherham

Two teenagers, a 14 year old girl and a 15 year old boy, died of
meningococcal disease on New Year's Eve. They lived about half a mile
apart in neighbouring communities of Rotherham, in South Yorkshire,
and attended different years of the same school. Both were infected with
Neisseria meningitidis, identified as serogroup C on the basis of
urinary antigen testing1 and confirmed, one by polymerase chain reaction
and one by isolates from blood culture and nasal swab.
Chemoprophylaxis and subsequently vaccination against serogroup C
were given to close contacts of the two cases and to all children at the
same school. A third teenager from the same area, a 16 year old girl, has
since been admitted to hospital as a suspected case. She belongs to the
same social network as the two teenagers that died and attended the same
school until June 1998. Prophylaxis (antibiotics and vaccine) is being
offered to an extended group of close social contacts who make up the
wider circle of friends of the three linked cases. Local public health
doctors have advised people to call an advice line if they have kissed on
the mouth or had prolonged and close social contact (for example, at a
private party or among friends at a pub) with any of the three cases.

A further case of confirmed serogroup C disease and three cases of
suspected meningitis in the same health district are not believed to be
linked to the outbreak.

1. Al-Wali W, Hughes C. Urine antigen detection can be quicker than
PCR in the diagnosis of meningococcal disease. J Hosp Infect 1998;
40: 326-8.
Two teenagers die in
outbreak of meningococcal
disease in Rotherham




















10

Salmonella infections:
monthly report

10

























13-16
Meningococcal disease in adolescence: an
integrated social, biological, and
psychological investigation

A two year case control study designed to investigate risk factors for the
development of meningococcal disease in teenagers aged 15 to 19 years
starts this week, funded by the Meningitis Research Foundation, and
supported by the Public Health Medicine Environmental Group. Previous
studies that have addressed risk factors for disease have included very
few teenagers, and a recent increase in the incidence of meningococcal
disease in this age group in the United Kingdom has made a large study
of adolescents vital. This study's results, which will be available in the
summer of 2000, should inform health promotion strategy or targeted
vaccination schemes.

Meningococcal disease in adolescence: an
integrated social, biological, and
psychological investigation

A two year case control study designed to investigate risk factors for the
development of meningococcal disease in teenagers aged 15 to 19 years
starts this week, funded by the Meningitis Research Foundation, and
supported by the Public Health Medicine Environmental Group. Previous
studies that have addressed risk factors for disease have included very
few teenagers, and a recent increase in the incidence of meningococcal
disease in this age group in the United Kingdom has made a large study
of adolescents vital. This study's results, which will be available in the
summer of 2000, should inform health promotion strategy or targeted
vaccination schemes.

continued on page 12
Influenza activity starts while Christmas
interrupts surveillance

Media interest in influenza over the Christmas period intensified in the
New Year, as it did two years ago1, as large numbers of hospital
consultations and admissions for respiratory infections were reported
throughout England and Wales. Rates of patients consulting general
practitioners for 'influenza and influenza-like illness' reported by the
Royal College of General Practitioners sentinel surveillance scheme
doubled from 94 per 100000 population in week 52/98 (ending 27
December 1998) to a provisional rate of 185/100000 in week 53/98
(ending 3 January 1998), remaining just below the threshold of
'increased seasonal activity' (>200 cases/100000) and some way below
the epidemic threshold (>400 cases/100000)2. Age specific rates
exceeding 200/100000 have been reported, however, in children under 4
years of age and adults aged 45 to 64 years
continued on page 12

Communicable Disease Report
Vol 9 No 2
8 Jan 1999
Meningococcal disease in adolescence: an integrated social,
biological, and psychological investigation (continued from page
9)

It is hoped that up to 200 cases will be recruited from six regions of England (Trent, Anglia and Oxford, North
Thames, South Thames, South and West, and West Midlands) over the next 15 months. A control matched for age
and sex will be sought from the list of each case's general practitioner. Subjects will be studied using questionnaires,
blood specimens, and throat swabs. Consultants in communicable disease control are asked to inform the study's
clinical research fellow, Dr Jo Tully, of cases of suspected meningococcal disease in teenagers between 15 and 19
years of age within 24 hours of their admission to hospital. Contact can be made between 0800 and 2300 seven days a
week as follows (contact details: Dr Jo Tully, clinical research fellow, Institute of Child Health, London, tel 0171 242
9789 ext 2443, mobile tel 07957 316172, email j.tully@ich.ucl.ac.uk).



To: Slugger who wrote (8320)1/17/1999 1:48:00 AM
From: aknahow  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 17367
 
Sorry for the last post. Cut and paste was sloppy with duplication. but this stuff comes from U.K. phls site. Note this one on reduction of mortality by early notification!!

2. Media reports of Meningitis

There has been a lot of media coverage of meningitis cases over the Christmas and New Year. There are two main
groups of meningococcal meningitis – Group B and C. The current vaccine is only effective against Group C. The
best protection is to be able to recognise the symptoms of meningitis and seek urgent medical attention if you suspect
someone has the disease. We know that we could reduce the deaths by as much as 50% if early recognition and
appropriate treatment are provided.



To: Slugger who wrote (8320)1/17/1999 7:04:00 PM
From: Tharos  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 17367
 
As you have said before, George, the FDA should only be in the business of determining safety, not efficacy, of drugs. We should have enough faith in our doctors to let them determine what drugs work best.

Your idea seems to work here in Japan.