To: nihil who wrote (29304 ) 1/29/1999 4:00:00 PM From: Ilaine Respond to of 108807
Well, I am not criticising your personal life. I am sure that you live it well. The point is that societal proscriptions with lengthy histories, such as the proscriptions against extramarital sex, have plusses as well as minuses. It's not something you would tend to notice in a western, urban environment, maybe, but closed societies are fragile, and acts which are contrary to the norm can be damaging. You only imagine that whom you have intercourse with has no effect on anyone but your willing partner. But, let's assume that you are a powerful superior (say, a teacher?) who has consensual sex with a willing subordinate (say, a graduate student?). This may be noticed by the others, other students, co-workers, and be damaging to morale. Many will be jealous, and feel injured thereby. You may find yourself favoring your protege in office politics, in a way which is contrary to perceived norms. Suppose you live in a village which only has a few score inhabitants. If you are a married man, and establish an adulterous relationship with a woman, you have taken her out of circulation, which may cause another man to do without a wife. A wife is not only a sexual partner, she is an economic partner, a mother, and a caregiver. So that man may be injured thereby. Suppose that once the woman is no longer nubile, she no longer attracts you and you end the relationship. She has "wasted" her best years, and may find it difficult to marry. A wealthy man can use up the best parts of countless women, leaving countless men without mates. In a world without effective birth control, cuckolded husbands will find themselves rearing the children of others, which is a waste of their own resources and does their own genes no good. Your spouse, whom you suppose to condone your relationships, may simply be powerless to stop you, and willing to lie about it to preserve peace and your good will. Similar arguments may be made against sodomy. I could go on, and on. My point being, that there are valid arguments to be made on both sides.