"...no one knows the true size of Internet use in China......
because many users share accounts...." ============================
November 16, 1998, Monday Foreign Desk NYTimes
A Trial Will Test China's Grip on the Internet
By ERIK ECKHOLM The trial of a 30-year-old computer executive, soon to begin in Shanghai, heralds a new electronic battleground for China's political dissidents and security forces determined to preserve Communist Party control.
Lin Hai, the defendant, is charged with ''inciting subversion of state power.'' Prosecutors say that from September 1997 until his arrest in March, Mr. Lin gave tens of thousands of Chinese E-mail addresses to ''hostile foreign publications.''
In particular, they say, he provided addresses to an electronic newsletter called VIP Reference, which is compiled by Chinese democracy advocates in Washington and sent to hundreds of thousands of computer-users inside China. According to the indictment, Mr. Lin helped the newsletter ''carry out propaganda and incitement by distributing essays inciting subversion of state power and overthrow of the socialist system.''
Mr. Lin appears to be the first legal casualty of a building struggle, as Internet users here and abroad make shreds of the Government's efforts to censor political debate and filter foreign news. VIP Reference -- which sends out reports on dissident activities, essays and reprinted articles on human rights and other issues -- is the most prominent of several electronic forums that are breaching China's information defenses.
''We're promoting freedom of speech on the Internet,'' said Feng Donghai, a software engineer at Columbia University who moved to the United States three years ago and helped start VIP Reference last fall. ''They are putting Lin Hai on trial to set an example.''
The main VIP Reference, sent out every 10 days, mostly includes essays and debates on democratic topics. A subsidiary Daily News edition, sent daily, includes detailed accounts of dissident initiatives and arrests.
The main newsletter is now sent to more than 250,000 addresses in China said its publisher, Lian Shengde, who spoke from Washington. The Daily News edition goes to about 25,000, and the numbers are steadily climbing as sympathizers send in lists of Chinese addresses.
The newsletter accepts addresses indiscriminately -- many are from commercially traded lists -- then mails to everyone. The theory is that when so many are automatic recipients, individuals cannot be accused of deliberately subscribing.
''We're posing a new problem for the Communists,'' said Mr. Lian, a software engineer in his 30's who moved from China after the 1989 military crackdown on student-led demonstrators in Beijing's Tiananmen Square. ''I don't think there's any way they can stop us.''
Another, similar publication is Tunnel, a self-described ''webzine'' of commentary written in China and sent electronically to the United States from where it is wired back to thousands of accounts inside China.
Addresses are, for VIP Reference, www.ifcss.org/ftp-pub/org/dck and for Tunnel, www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Bay/5598. Chinese-script software is required.
A third newsletter, Public Opinion, is edited and distributed electronically from inside China. It includes commentaries and reprints of items taken off the Internet and is produced by a group of young computer company workers who call themselves ''political netters.''
Over the last year, these newsletters, plus assorted on-line discussion groups, have become important means of communication among political activists, said Xiao Qiang, executive director of Human Rights in China in New York.
China now has some 1.2 million Internet accounts, many shared by several users, with the numbers zooming. The Government has encouraged hookups in the interest of promoting national development, but is fighting a losing battle to control political uses.
Chinese officials use an electronic ''firewall'' to block access to web sites it deems objectionable, including those of human rights groups and some considered pornographic. But it cannot keep up with new sites, and clever users can sidestep the firewall. E-mail is virtually uncontrollable, although agents can identify a particular individual and read that person's mail.
China's security agencies have formed special units to fight not only conventional computer crimes like illegal break-ins and fraud, but also the spread of dissident information. To evade Government filters and electronic disruptions, VIP Reference is mailed from a different American address every day.
Somehow, the authorities zeroed in on Mr. Lin. Last week, Mr. Lin's wife, Xu Hong, learned that his trial will begin on Nov. 26 but will be a closed proceeding so that she cannot attend. The lawyers she hired will be present but, Ms. Xu said by telephone, ''I'm afraid the lawyers won't have much influence on the results.''
If convicted as charged, Mr. Lin may face a prison sentence of five years or more. He and his wife have a 20-month-old son.
Ms. Xu, who says her husband is innocent, said that E-mail addresses are ''public information, like telephone books, which can be exchanged or purchased.'' He has never been involved in politics, she said.
===================================
January 21, 1999, Thursday Foreign Desk
E-Mail to U.S. Lands Chinese Internet Entrepreneur in Jail
By SETH FAISON A court here sentenced a computer engineer to two years in jail today in a case watched closely by people monitoring official efforts to control China's growing use of the Internet.
The Shanghai No. 1 Intermediate Court ruled that Lin Hai, 30, committed a subversive act last year when he sent 30,000 Chinese E-mail addresses to VIP Reference, an electronic publication based in the United States that the Chinese authorities consider hostile to Beijing.
Mr. Lin, who was arrested last March, ran a software company that set up Web sites and offered other Internet-related services. Mr. Lin's wife, Xu Hong, said her husband was not interested in politics and had simply been exchanging E-mail addresses to build a database for his on-line business.
But prosecutors argued that the names provided by Mr. Lin had been used to distribute ''large numbers of articles aimed at inciting subversion of state power and the socialist system.''
VIP Reference, one of many electronic publications that distribute news about China, is compiled by Chinese democracy advocates in Washington. Editors of the newsletter say they send information to 250,000 E-mail accounts in China.
Efforts to restrict the exchange of political information on the Internet, these editors contend, are fruitless because of the volume and variety of electronic commerce.
Chinese officials formally embrace use of the Internet as a necessary part of efforts to modernize their economy and society. At the same time, special task forces monitor political content on the Internet and block some Web sites carrying information that Beijing deems unfriendly.
Although no one knows the true size of Internet use in China because many users share accounts, one recent official estimate said 2.1 million people in China were on the Internet by the end of 1998, up from 670,000 a year earlier.
In such a fast-growing environment, the case against Mr. Lin looks like a throwback to an earlier era, when Beijing had tighter control of the spread of information. It may also reflect a decision by the authorities to make an example of someone seen to be helping a publication like VIP Reference, if only indirectly.
Mr. Lin's two-year sentence, harsh by any international standard, is relatively light for a charge of political subversion in China. In a recent crackdown on efforts to set up a democratic political party, three leading dissidents were given sentences ranging from 11 to 13 years in prison.
In a country where the official media offer dull versions of the news, some Chinese on-line services feel freer to provide flashy news accounts that do not go through the same official censors as newspapers, television and radio.
Although the Communist authorities would clearly like to maintain their once-firm control over access to information, they are steadily becoming overwhelmed by the growth in more open communication -- by telephone, fax and now by Internet -- that has come with efforts to modernize China's economy.
The official New China News Agency reported today that a recent survey of young people, ages 14 to 28, found an overwhelming hunger for access to the Intenet. But 69 percent of those surveyed said they had no way to get on line.
Only 3.4 percent of the young people said they surfed the Internet regularly. At the same time, only 7 percent said they had no interest in the Internet, and 6 percent said they had not heard of it.
''There is still a long way to go before the Internet becomes truly popular among Chinese youth,'' the news agency concluded. |