To: Frank A. Coluccio who wrote (22953 ) 2/21/1999 3:34:00 PM From: Curtis E. Bemis Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 77400
Frank-- Two times is sufficient for an invitation ;-)) I enjoy your informative posts on the many threads we cross on. The wonders of the cyber-world. I have a hard time keeping up with you!!..edge routing, while I was trying to lure my cyber-mentor Curtis into a debate! OK, I'm getting sucked in-- Here are a few of my views on what is happening in the BIG net. ISPs are changing to meet the needs of the customers that they serve. The customers require secure connections and that invokes firewalls; customers require security, authentication, encryption and all that--that invokes the whole suite of things in what is called IPSEC, and the RFC's that describe it. Virtual Private Networks, VPN's, which can be constructed using tunnels (GRE tunnels), are required and all the *quality* kinds of issues that go with all the above. Packet classification to allow all of these things to happen is important and all of this is done at the edge. Throw VOIP in there ;-). So, if this is what you mean by taking the current intelligence out of the core, then I agree--BUT--the intelligence requirements in the core have changed--not getting stupid--just changing. The core needs bandwidth--the edge gets more complex. The final end customer of an ISP is currently bandwidth limited and fancy *quality* things have to be invoked to allow that customer to choose the groomed traffic that will flow to them. Tis getting better on the bandwidth front with competition--take NYC as an example. You have some cool bypass folks in operation there--MFNX, LVLT and more. Heck, I remember when a intra-LATA DS1 costs 10K/month. You can get a DS3 from that now, maybe even an OC-3c. Europe is bandwidth deprived by PTNs but I see changes happening. So, is that enough for a debate or questions ?? I got suckered ;-))