To: Tom who wrote (2709 ) 3/2/1999 9:42:00 AM From: WONG Respond to of 2951
And you want to lend money to these guys???Negative worth estimated at $13b LANA WONG (SCMP) Guangdong Enterprises (Holdings) had a negative net worth of $13.17 billion at the end of September, after incurring a larger than expected exceptional loss of $17.92 billion in the first nine months of last year. The information was revealed by accounting firm KPMG, appointed by the Guangdong provincial government to audit its Hong Kong investment arms for the period.A creditor bank official said: "Why is there such a big difference in their accounts? Has their reporting accountant done a proper job?" GDE's reporting accountant Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu was not available for comment yesterday. Some accountants reasoned KPMG had to be "ultra-conservative" in preparing the statements during GDE's troubled times and it had made large-enough provisions to clean up the company's balance sheet to ensure there would be no unpleasant surprises when financial data to the end of December was released. GDE had earlier cited improper accounting procedures and bad investment and management decisions as some of the reasons for the significant impairment in revenue and assets. Guangdong executive vice-governor Wang Qishan said he did not expect material changes in the financial positions of GDE and Guangnan (Holdings) in the period to December. The exceptional items included mainly provisions for bad and doubtful accounts. GDE's 40.5 per cent-held Guangdong Investment (GDI) showed a net loss of $2.18 billion in the period, dragged down mainly by a $1.88 billion exceptional loss on the fall in value of property, listed investments and provisions for doubtful debts. GDI's loss would result in technical defaults on loans, prompting it to start negotiations with bankers on debt rescheduling. It is understood its talks with banks would be easier for GDI than for GDE and Guangnan as it maintained a net asset value of more than $6 billion, meaning all creditors were expected to be repaid in full. GDI would probably emerge in the best position if the group is successfully restructured, as the potential assets to be injected into GDE fall in line with GDI's business focus. After the restructuring, GDI would focus on utilities, infrastructure, property and hotels. This would mean its interest in listed arms Guangdong Brewery Holdings, Guangdong Tannery, Guangdong Building Industries, and its manufacturing and finance businesses would be disposed of. Assets identified for possible injection into GDE include Dongjiang River water supply, which supplies water to Hong Kong and Shenzhen and has projected revenue of 2.73 billion yuan (about HK$2.54 billion) this year. Others include minority stakes in Shaoguan Power Plant D, Shantou Bay Bridge, Humen Bridge, the Huizhou section of the Guangzhou-Shantou Highway, Qinglian Highway, Huaji Highway, Yuehui Highway and Bridge and Huiguang Highway and Bridge. The identified assets are expected to be ultimately injected from GDE into GDI through the firm taking over part of GDE's debts and issuing new shares to the parent, a source familiar with the restructuring plan said. GDI would in no way be merged with Guangnan as it would defeat the purpose of streamlining their operations with a clear business focus, sources said. So far, none of the potential asset-injection targets are in line with Guangnan's businesses. Market observers wondered whether Guangnan's creditor banks would eventually need to face a cut in loan principal repayments or see the firm go bust, if it did not receive asset injections to return it into positive net worth position. Guangnan, 56.9 per cent held by GDE, showed a negative net worth of $1.28 billion as of September. It plunged into a loss of $3.29 billion, after booking exceptional items of $3.4 billion that included $2.28 billion in provisions for bad and doubtful debts.