To: Rex Dwyer who wrote (219 ) 3/5/1999 2:12:00 PM From: pat mudge Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 2347
A few quotes on the DOCSIS process from recently released CMTO report: "We believe there is significant investor confusion about the Data Over Cable Service Interface Specification (DOCSIS) which was created by CableLabs, a cable industry consortium. DOCSIS 1.0 was defined with the primary goal of offering interoperable cable modems, so that once certified, consumer's can purchase a DOCSIS-certified modem and use it with any vendor's headend equipment. Although no vendor has been DOCSIS 1.0-certified, 11 vendors including Com21, 3Com, Cisco, Bay Networks (Nortel Networks), Toshiba, E-Tech, General Instruments, Samsung, Sony, Thomson, and Zenith have submitted their products to CableLabs for certification. We expect that CableLabs will announce the vendors that have passed the rigorous DOCSIS 1.0 certification program later this week [see 3/4/99 press release: Message 8148969 ] with DOCSIS 1.0 certified modems likely to be available in volume during the second quarter of 1999. It is not known which vendors will ultimately be certified. DOCSIS 1.1 specifications have been authored and will be finalized in the April-May time frame, and feature fragmentation, concatenation, and quality of service features to offer toll quality voice over cable. We expect DOCSIS 1.1 certified products to be available in the last quarter of 1999. Finally, DOCSIS 1.2 specifications are in the preliminary drafting phase with finalization expected toward the end of this year. The primary feature incorporated into the DOCSIS 1.2 specification is support for the S-CDMA modulation scheme which will allow cable modems to operate in the very noisy or "dirty" cable plants. We do not expect DOCSIS 1.2-certified products to be available until mid-2000. On the international front, we estimate that markets outside the United States are about one year behind in standards selections. Multivendor interoperability is the foundation of DOCSIS and consequently, DOCSIS 1.2 and 1.1 are subsets of 1.0 and require backward compatibility. All DOCSIS standards are openly published and all vendors have royalty-free access to the intellectual property needed to build a standard-compliant cable modem system. Consequently, vendors that are selected to author a particular DOCSIS standard do not have any meaningful advantage over vendors not included in the authoring process. Finally, despite DOCSIS standards, we expect many cable modem vendors to offer value-added features in their cable modem solutions in order to distinguish their products, including support for: higher speeds, superior noise reduction techniques, and virtual private networking features. Stock Opinion. . . The cable modem market has significant market growth potential and Com21 has the products, customers, distribution, and management team to deliver results. We are raising our price target to $40 from $25 based on 10X calendar 1999 revenues, consistent with other high-growth franchise networking names. The stock remains rated Strong Buy-Aggressive." [Dain Rauscher Wessels] Investment summary from Credit Suisse First Boston: CMTO: A Compelling Data Over Cable Play  Resuming coverage with a BUY rating; Increasing 1999 top-line estimate to $87 million from $76.5 million and 2000 revenue forecast to $130 million from $120 million; Project 1999 EPS of ($0.44) and 2000 EPS of $0.25.  Momentum continuing with proprietary system installs; Introduction of DOCSIS product line creates incremental growth opportunities.  Initial DOCSIS vendor certifications scheduled to be released by CableLabs on March 4, CMTO well positioned for certification; However, any delays in certification would not be material to our outlook or the company's strategic position.  Estimate Q1: 99 is tracking favorably relative to our $18 million top-line and ($0.15) bottom-line estimate; 9-12 month price target + $35. [DRW's estimates: FY 1999 EPS ($0.37) on $85 million revs; and 2000 EPS of $0.16 on $130 million revs.]