Afterhours Trading - Lessons from the Trenches (from our free e-newsletter; send email to tdesk@yamner.com with words SUBSCRIBE in subject)
Trading after-hours and pre-open can often appear as a world of its own. Most investors feel they have no access to such trading. Yamner & Co., Inc. fully offers pre-open and after-hours trading through many of our execution system. Nonetheless, accessibility and prudence are two different things. While many perceive there to be significant upside to pre-open trading, few rarely perceive the risks. Yet there are significant risks.
The hours of operation for the US equity markets is from 9:30am through 4pm, Eastern Standard Time. During these hours, on both listed and OTC exchanges, there exists parties who are responsible for maintaining an orderly market in a stock, standing ready with firm quotes, prices at which they will sell (offer) stock as well as buy (bid) for stock. And while you may not like or be satisfied with the prices that these parties post on your security, you will at minimum know that there is a market, regardless of price, for your stock.
In the over-the-counter markets, such as the Nasdaq National markets, these parties are known as market makers, firms who act as principals in their clients' transactions, taking the other side to the trade, while presenting firm bids and offers. On listed exchanges, such the New York Stock Exchange, this individual is referred to as the specialist.
And while the specialist and market maker are required to post firm bids and offers on their respective securities, these bids and offers are only firm during market hours, from 9:30am through 4pm. Thus, moments before the market opens and immediately at the close, without access to after hours trading systems, you effectively have no liquid access to the markets. Regardless of the pre-open volatility in the stock, market makers and specialists have every right to say, "not open, nothing done yet'.
There are strategies to successfully navigating these markets. Trading in the after hours or pre-open will vary depending on the particular stock and its primary exchange. Lets start with the NASDAQ.
The Nasdaq is more investor-friendly when it comes to trading after-hours. While market makers generally are uninterested in executing after the bell or pre-open, you can often find a market maker or an investor that is willing to do the trade. It takes some work, a few systems and skill.
The systems that I might utilize include, but are not limited to:
1. Phone based trading to various market makers; market makers on the offer, other liquid market makers 2. SelectNet based trading to " " " " 3. ECN access; actively taking out an offer or hitting a bid; or more passively posting a bid or offer.
If a client were interested in buying after the bell, I will immediately go to the market maker that was on the offer at the close. Being on the offer, the firm was displaying an interest in selling. Was is the key word. My hopes would be that the market maker was unable to find a buyer and still has a position to work. Perhaps the firm has a client order to sell at that limit and would like to clean up the ticket. The contra firm might have the discretion to trade the position after-hours. My recommended first course of action for trading after the bell would be go to the market maker on the offer. I would probably start with a direct linkage system or phone, then move to SNET.
If the firm(s) with the closing offer declines my trade, I would then probably go to one of the leading market makers in the stock, perhaps MASH, TSCO or NITE. With high volume trading desks, these firms might have gone home with long positions that the traders are interested in cleaning up before heading home for the evening. Perhaps these firms have the other side and are simply interested in cleaning up one more ticket.
If either of those fail options, I now have to make a critical decision as to how to approach the stock. My analysis here would goes as follow: First, I would analyze the after hours transactions which are occurring if any. There may be other stocks trading after hours and an analysis of the times and sales for these stocks might quickly tell you where stock is changing hands. Actually, this analysis applies regardless of the system you are utilizing. Always check times and sales after the bell or before the open. Since market makers "freeze" their quotes after-hours, times and sales is the more prudent technology for determining where the stock is trading is the extended sessions.
The most utilized system for trading after hours in the OTC markets involves the use of ECNs. ECNs permit a client to instantly place a bid or ask on an OTC stock, visible to the entire market. There are a tremendous number of issues relating to manning rules and obligations of market makers to publish client quotes, etc., yet for our sake, lets just say that using an ECN gives the client immediate access to the market. The clients' bid or offer is instantly published.
Electronic Communication Networks are a critical, though not the end-all; they are simply component of modern trading. We use ECNs in approximately 14% of the trades that we execute. We typically feel that during the market hours, unless you are joining the bid or joining the offer, more passive means of trading, we have many other executions systems that offer better results. Nonetheless, when it comes to after-hours trading, ECNs get the nod.
Most ECNs do permit trading after-hours. It is simply a matter of the client posting a bid or offer and another client taking down that offer or hitting the posted bid. For example, at 4:30, after the market has closed, if you desire to buy stock ABCD, and you have exhausted your first few options, you would need to look for an ECN offer. Scour up and down a Nasdaq Level2 screen and look for an ECN offering stock. The most common ECNs include INCA, ISLD and REDI, though there are several others. These ECNS are "live". That is, if you have access to them, you can execute a trade after-hours. A bid or offer posted at any time the ECNs is online is a live order. Enter a erroneous price, and you quickly learn how costly the improper use of an ECN can be.
Access is the key. You need a firm that has either direct or indirect linkages to these ECNs. For the record, Yamner & Co., Inc. has access to virtually every ECN, offering our clients the broadest range of systems for after-hours trading.
Note that the ECN bid or offer may deviate significantly from where the stock is printing in after-hours trading. For example, a stock might continue to print at 9 after-hours, yet the lowest ECN is offering stock at 10. One could decide to route an order to the live offer at 10, yet the client might be better suited to place a passive bid at 9 or 9 1/16 on the ECN, thus establishing an after-hours bid, displaying to the world that you wish to buy stock at 9 1/16. If sellers persist, your 9 1/16 bid has a better chance of being hit.
Note that the Nasdaq, in all trading session, offers no 'trade-through' protection. You may have a bid at 9 1/16, yet stock might be trading at 9. This might seem disappointing and you feel you should be entitled to a fill. On the Nasdaq, it is a negotiated market. Someone must hit your bid specifically.
Nonetheless, placing a passive bid does not ensure that you will own the stock. No one might hit your bid and you end up without your position. If the stock opens the next day at 20, it would have, in retrospect, been a wise move to have paid up and bought the stock at 10. Only retrospect helps here. The stock could also open at 2, proving the decision to be a foolish one.
With listed stocks you have fewer options. On listed stocks, my first move would be to bid or offer the stock on the PCOAST, the Pacific Coast Stock Exchange. While not as active as the NYSE, the Pcoast offers the advantage of extended hours, trading to 4:30pm est. Thus sellers or buyers that evaluate positions and are interested in additional activity might simply go to the Pcoast as it is a centralized, listed exchange upon which they can trade stock.
If the PCOAST proves fruitless, then Instinet, the ECN mentioned above, permits traders to trade listed stocks after-hours. Again, one must analyze their book to see the various prices at which stock is bid for or offered. This lets a trader know where one can actively get or sell stock, though again, these prices may significantly vary with the stocks' close or after-hour prints.
The prices at which stocks trade after-hours can often deviate tremendously from where the stock opens the next day. A general lack of liquidity typically is the biggest factor driving the volatility. Traders and firms are adjusting their prices relative to this lack of liquidity, a lack of understanding of where the broad market will open the following session, etc.
I often caution investors that there are typically bigger, better funded parties out there who know exactly what they are doing at the open. If our Trading Desk has 100,000 shares of ABCD to sell at the market at the open for one client, it would be foolish for some unknowing party to bid for the stock too aggressively. As well, most traders with size, as well as those traders handling client orders for large houses, probably don't show up to work until 8:30, 9am. (As a side note, we staff our trading desk from 6:30 am, available for pre-open trading,). This is similar to being allowed into a shopping mall a hour before it opens, only to find yourself walking the hallways with all the stores closed. The prices from last night look great but without a vendor will to sell to you, there is nothing that can be done. Without a contra firm, access to the markets pre-open means nothing.
In addition to the speculative component of after-hours trading, such trading can be quite helpful when a trader makes an error on a stock. For example, a trader may believe they had sold an entire position when infact only a partial fill was executed. As a result, the trader may make the prudent move of eliminating the position after-hours. While the price may deviate, it might be considered a worthy consideration given the risks perceived by the trader of holding the stock overnight. Some consider it insurance.
While there are significant risks associated with trading during these periods, as volume on the exchanges continues to grow, traders will look for every opportunity to process trades. Ultimately, the savvy trader should at least have an understanding of how such markets operate, as well as be with a firm that fully understands the complexities of such trading. Yamner & Co., Inc. is fully experienced and technically equipped to handle this component of business if our clients desire it.
*********************************** The Hard Right Edge Technical Analysis by Alan Farley
Alan Farley is a trader and editor of The Hard Right Edge web site. The Hard Right Edge provides comprehensive traders resources including original tutorials and strategies on multi-trend technical analysis and short-term trading . Alan also authors complete on-line training courses on technical analysis in association with independent sites. He has been featured in Barrons and Smart Money magazine.Visit The Hard Right Edge at hardrightedge.com.
Perfect Trade Entry
Successful traders must manage time better than investors. Executing short-term positions requires far more skill than just buying a stock and holding it. But trading has a more attractive time/cash profile than investing. In other words, you can make a lot more money quickly. But you can lose it even faster without thoughtful preparation.
Short-termers exploit individual quirks of market behavior and take fast, high probability profits. And you don't need a lot of different methods. Some futures traders earn a good living just selling the same 5-min ledge formation over and over again. While not as crowd pleasing as chasing EBAY or SEEK, these well timed entries produce extremely high percentages of profitable trades.
Focus on optimizing entry and exit over all other considerations. Fully understand the time character of each part of the market day. For example, never buy weakness in the last hour if price is near the bottom of its daily range. Time of day sentiment favors continued declines for issues near their lows at this time.
Remember this golden rule of trading: over time, excellent entries on mediocre trades make more money than bad entries on good ones. Consider trading single direct moves rather than holding through inevitable pullbacks. Increase position size or improve the time/cash profile to risk more money. Or only scale in with part of a position while waiting for the next big price move.
Cross verification must be part of your trading analysis. When identical price hot spots appear in different forms of evaluation, odds increase that position will succeed. An assumption exists that each new verification (convergence at a specific price zone) raises the positive to negative feedback ratio. At rare times, Fibonacci retracements, moving averages and trendlines all work together in perfect unison. When they do, jump on board quickly.
CAPTION 1.
yamner.com yamner.com
Sometimes the fog lifts and the trading message becomes crystal clear. As General Electric descended into a well-deserved correction, four classic pattern measurements pointed to a reversal at the exact same point. This rare CVx4 revealed a perfect time/cash profile setup. |