To: Walter in HK who wrote (6238 ) 3/8/1999 12:18:00 AM From: Paul Senior Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 78476
Hello Walter in HK. Well, we again come down to the likelihood that there are many definitions of 'value investing'. Any or all of which might be effective depending on the practitioner. I look at value investing from a Ben Graham perspective, I think. This would be a method that IMO, focuses on safety of principle and gaining an adequate return. Unlike Weitz's, it does not test for honesty of management or attempt to determine "franchise" value or other intangibles. From what I garner rereading your quoted Weitz material, Weitz seeks capital gain, primarily from a few investments where he/his analysts have detailed knowledge of the businesses. In Graham's writings IMO, and with my investment approach certainly, there's more of an emphasis on diversification rather than emphasizing detailed business knowledge and thus holding fewer issues. Anyone looking at the Weitz stocks I mentioned will see they are not houshold names -- not in any households I'm familiar with anyway -g-. To have come across such companies in Oct. of '98 - anyone buying them had to have some very good insight and knowledge of their business and their business prospects. Or spend the time getting that knowledge. There were just so many other statistically-and-obviously cheap companies that value investors could have bought. These Weitz companies didn't and don't look like the value companies I am looking for. But... if they are the "value" type companies you are seeking, they might be winners for you. As far as what value type companies people on this thread are looking for, I speak only for myself. May I suggest though that you also check out the "Buffettology" thread here on SI? It was created in recognition of the difference between the Buffett style and the Graham style. Regards, Paul Senior ps: If I might politely inquire, do you have any HK stocks that you like at their present prices? I'd be interested in ones that would be listed on our NYSE or NASDQ.