To: Ahda who wrote (32991 ) 5/2/1999 5:40:00 PM From: Alex Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 116791
Japan's debt time bomb By AKIO OGAWA Special to Asahi Evening News The Ministry of Finance (MOF) predicts that the total debt of Japan's central and local governments will hit 600 trillion yen by the end of fiscal 1999, in March 2000. Any Japanese who has not been to Mars in the past few months knows this. What is not known is how to pay the huge debt, which amounts to almost eight times the size of the nation's 1999 budget. Many lawmakers have raised the question repeatedly since January at the plenary and committee debate sessions in both the Lower and Upper houses. During these sessions, Prime Minister Keizo Obuchi and Finance Minister Kiichi Miyazawa have repeatedly said, "When we get out of the current economic slump in a few years, we can stop floating bonds and start paying off the debt." Obuchi and Miyazawa have sought to leave the impression that economic growth of a few percentage points could erase the red figure in a matter of a few years. But many economists and MOF officials know this is just a joke. They know that such growth would bring only a trillion yen or less a year in added revenues. Despite this knowledge, they have remained silent about the nation's biggest taboo. Once the truth is out, they fear, the nation could be thrown into chaos, toppling a government or two. But the truth is out, finally. Heizo Takenaka, professor of economics at Keio University, has just broken the taboo in his latest book, "Keisei Saimin" (Statecraft and the rescue of the Japanese people), published by Diamondo-sha (1,600 yen). Consumption tax could skyrocket In the book the professor bluntly says, "The consumption tax must be raised to 14 percent outright from the current 5 percent or the nation's public works budget must be cut by 80 percent" to deal with the 600 trillion yen in debt. A 14 percent consumption tax would deal an unimaginable blow to the all-important consumer spending, triggering an economic disaster. We still remember that former prime minister Ryutaro Hashimoto raised the tax by 2 percent in April 1997 and threw the country into an ever-deepening economic quagmire. Japan's spending on public works projects totals 50 trillion yen a year and the past spending spree has played a key role in generating the debt. But an 80 percent cut would reduce the figure to a 10 trillion yen, forcing most of the country's 560,000 construction firms, small and large, into bankruptcy. If the construction industry crashes, the nation's economy could go bust. It is important to note that Takenaka put the estimates on the table at the Economic Strategy Council, a blue-ribbon advisory body set up by Obuchi in August 1998 to map out a blueprint for an economic revival for the 21st century. He served as a council member. We now know that the estimates were behind the nine-member council's final report, published in late February 1999. The report suggested raising the consumption tax but stopped short of stating by how much, for fear of pouring further cold water on the economy and starting a political firestorm. Readers will be in for a shock because Takenaka says his drastic theoretical proposals, apparently endorsed by his peers on the council and MOF officials, would only bring the nation's snowballing debts down to what he calls "primary balance" in 10 years--when Japan needs not to float new bonds any longer. Japan would still be facing a mountain of debt equal to 3 percent of the GDP. Takenaka's book is terrifying enough to send a cold shiver down anyone's spine. But Akira Moriki, an economic commentator, says that a consumption tax higher than 20 percent is necessary to bring the nation's debt into primary balance. When you read Moriki's latest book, "Shohizei ga 20 percent wo koe, Ichidoru ga 200 yen to Naru Koredake no Riyu" (The many reasons why the consumption tax could top 20 percent and the dollar could rise to 200 yen), you would notice that Takenaka might have overlooked or failed to mention a figure or two. In his book, published by Daini Kaientai (1,700 yen), Moriki notes that the nation's debt will not total just 600 trillion yen by next March, but will top 689.3 trillion yen. The 600-trillion yen figure, now a household word, does not include what Moriki calls "hidden debt," refunding bonds and other borrowed money. The "hidden debt" refers to a variety of contributions the central government is legally obliged to pay into the nation's health care, pension and other programs but has failed to do so. "Refunding bonds" mean new bonds issued to raise funds to pay back matured bonds. Such funding bonds add more debt, ballooning the nation's debt faster than projected by MOF. Moriki warns that the consumption tax could be raised to as high as 25 percent, water supply fees and public housing rents could be raised, garbage collection could be charged for, free health checks for pregnant mothers and infants could be abolished and free medical services for the aged could also go. "The inflation and raised taxes would hit every facet of our daily life. The government might freeze postal savings. Pension payments for anyone 40 years old or younger now might evaporate by the time they retire," Moriki says. And a senior analyst working for a research institute attached to a major bank told this writer: "We have just figured the consumption tax must be raised to 18 percent to tame the rampaging debt." Japan's biggest problem--or economic scandal--is so outrageous that it appears that no politician or ordinary citizen dares confront the reality, wishing it would go away. It will not, if you are to believe these books.