To: jackson who wrote (3704 ) 5/5/1999 2:19:00 PM From: chris431 Respond to of 18366
We are obviously not discussing "portable" in the same sense. Walter, in the original post to which I responded about the ZIP, was referring to a portable device (portable cd/cassette player, Diamond RIO, etc.), not medium. Of course, ZIP is sufficient for a storage medium for which to transport media. So is a pull out 18GB hard drive. But, none of these devices would work well packaged within a self-operating device (portable device). As such they are unlikely to be used in a "portable" device for which you carry around for the sole purpose of accessing the data on the move, not simply store it. ZIPs are simply too bulky compared to the competition that is available. The Clik is interesting....especially the "Click of Death." <g> (Beware!) I see little reason to go with Clik when Flash is already available above 40mb, has no moving parts, and is likely to be comparably priced (and doesn't come with the negative's of Iomega's history of making storage mediums which love to eat your data). Another thing...."swapping titles with friends" is not something the new distribution mechanism will encourage or allow (which is the major problem with unsecure MP3, which is why we are all here). A device to port the music between your own players is another issue. A zip disk could be sufficient for that as would any portable storage device. We'll see how it all works out....DSS key card like system? Never know but we'll find out eventually. Clearly flash is the dominant storage medium for the new storage devices. Most, if not all of the current devices currently on the market use flash. CD is a very interesting format as well but the problem is that most of the broad market does not have easy access to a cd-r. The IBM Micro Drive also has a great deal of potential. "Clik"....hahahahaha, not likely to make much of an impact at 40mb. As such, I find it unlikely given the current competition that a manufacturer will create a portable device using the bulky ZIP disk, or HD. Chris