To: Satish C. Shah who wrote (4245 ) 5/10/1999 11:05:00 AM From: Mohan Marette Respond to of 12475
Ref:"Father India' by Jeffery Paine. Hi Satish: I haven't read the book so I am at a disadvantage here.Have you read it? Why are you upset anyway? I read mixed reviews about it some good some not so good. Here is one not so good.'... A reader from New York , February 12, 1999 Interesting tales, but a third-hand view of India Paine tells engaging stories about Curzon, Besant, Forster, Naipaul, Isherwood, Mirra Richard. But these are 2nd hand stories, and they are stories that reflect India another step removed. In itself the book is fine, but it fails to live up to the promise in the title. Paine should have looked at Thoreau, Emerson, Schopenhauer, Schrodinger for more direct influences. Or even if he chose this frame, the least he needed was to understand 'Father India' for himself. If he had, a lot of rhetorical questions he asks in the book from time to time would have yielded their answers. Where is the tiger in the jungle? to repeat Hesse's old question. Since Paine doesn't know, his stories rank at the level of an English professor spinning yarns not about a subject directly, but about the lives of various people who dealt with it! and here is one that is all praises but obviously failed to see what the reader above have noticed. From Booklist , October 15, 1998Gandhi was once asked what he thought of Western civilization. "I think it would be a good idea," he answered. Paine has fashioned a fascinating and eminently readable account of how Western minds have been influenced by India. He devotes time to the British reformers Lord Curzon and Annie Besant; writers E. M. Forster, William Yeats, V. S. Naipaul, Allen Ginsberg, and Christopher Isherwood; and thinker-reformers Carl Jung and Martin Luther King Jr., among others. He even charts Gandhi's interaction with his own country. Once, a trip to India meant "quasi-enchanted travel to the far horizons of the possible." Paine goes beyond the spices and smells to decipher the true attraction of India for these modern figures and how they translated their findings back to the West. In some cases it meant Hinduism, in others it meant a new mix of spirituality and politics, but more often it meant an inner transformation, something far less definable. Paine does a bang-up job of providing the definitions. Highly recommended. David Cline.