Gabelli Growth: Why it Dumped Consumer Staple Stocks
Associate Editor: Len Hollie
Howard Ward is uneasy.
The Gabelli Growth fund (NASDAQ:GABGX - news) manager sold all of his Coca-Cola (NYSE:KO - news) , Gillette (NYSE:G - news) and Procter & Gamble (NYSE:PG - news) positions in April. This marks the first time that the fund has not held any large consumer staple growth stocks.
'I am concerned that this is the first time that the fund has not held any of those stocks,' concedes Ward, who has managed the $2 billion fund since 1995. 'I also don't own G.E. (NYSE:GE - news) or Wal-Mart (NYSE:WMT - news) , and I do feel exposed to the S&P 500 in so far as not owning the large cap stocks. But, I'd rather be one of the first ones out of a sector than one of the last ones in.'
In their place, Ward has added Intel (NASDAQ:INTL - news), AT&T (NYSE:T - news) and MCI Worldcom (NASDAQ:WCOM - news) .
'I feel that the growth in the U.S. economy is predominantly in the information technology industry,' says Ward. 'I strongly believe that in a growth fund, you want the wind at your back. And there is none in large cap consumer growth stocks. But there is wind at your back in the information technology stocks.'
Ward says Coca-Cola, Gillette and Procter & Gamble have been uniformly overpriced and all of them have been stumbling. He notes that their growth expectations have come down, but the declines have not been fully registered in their valuations.
Indeed, Coke closed at $68.50 on Wednesday, down from its high of $88.94. But it still trades at about 50 times trailing 12 months earnings. Gillette closed at $50.94, down from $64.38, but still 53 times trailing earnings. P&G closed at $95.75, nearly 35 times earnings and just $8 off its 52-week high.
'If I owned them now with a low cost in taxable accounts I probably wouldn't sell them,' Ward concedes, since they would generate huge capital gains bills for shareholders. But he adds, 'I don't think they are among the 50 best values in the market. I would not want to go back and buy these stocks until they were at least 15% to 20% lower than they are today.'
Escalating stock prices also prompted Ward to reduce the fund's position in Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT - news) last month from 3.5% of the portfolio to 1.2%. Mr. Softee closed Wednesday at $78.50, down from its 52-week high of $95.63, but still more than 62 times trailing earnings.
'I cut the stake when the stock price was in the mid-$90 range. But now that it's fallen to the $70s, it's starting to look attractive to me,' concedes Ward. 'But I'd be reluctant to add more Microsoft to the portfolio, mainly because I only want 25% of the money in the portfolio in the tech sector.'
'If I didn't have a 25% restriction, I'd buy it now,' he adds. 'But I think IBM (NYSE:IBM - news) , which at 5% of the portfolio and is my biggest tech stake, is a better value than Microsoft. I think Sun Microsystems (NASDAQ:SUNW - news) and Cisco (NASDAQ:CSCO - news) are better values. I wouldn't want to lose them in order to add more Microsoft.'
Ward also sold the fund's entire stake of 750,750 shares of Charles Schwab (NYSE:SCH - news) in April for more than $19 million because the price had climbed too high. He notes that Schwab was beginning to trade like an Internet stock, and he has steadfastly shunned the high-flying sector. To be sure, Scwab rose to a high of $155 from a 52-week low of just $18.50. However, on Wednesday it closed at $108.75, up $12.13.
'When you're running a mutual fund, the goal is to beat the S&P 500,' Ward notes. 'And, if I can't do that, then what's the point. This might as well be an index fund.'
To his credit, Ward has been slightly better than the benchmark S&P 500. So far this year (through Tuesday), the fund is up 5.71%, beating the S&P by 0.81 percentage points. In 1998, the fund returned 29.79% and bested the S&P by 1.21 points.
Other stocks among the fund's top 10 holdings are Home Depot (NYSE:HD - news) , Northern Trust (NASDAQ:NTRS - news) , Cisco Systems, Marsh & McLennan (NYSE:MMC - news) , Sun Microsystems, and Time Warner (NYSE:TWX - news) .
Is Ward mulling a return to large consumer staples any time soon? He concedes they are normally a core holding for large cap growth funds, and that at some point he may go back to them.
But, he says: 'I'll be very surprised if that happens by the end of the year, unless the stock prices get much lower than they are right now.'
|