SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Strategies & Market Trends : India Coffee House -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Mohan Marette who wrote (4310)5/22/1999 3:18:00 AM
From: Satish C. Shah  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 12475
 
Father India - revisited

Hello Mohan:

I have emotional attachments to India that is why Father India made me sick. Mr Paine trashes everything Indian he comes across.

Last time I was this sick was when I was reading Jean Ganet's "diary of a Thief". Marquis de Sade was ok, even "the story of O" was ok.

1, criticizes Gandhi for the white suit he was wearing when he landed in England as a 19 year old. ( criticize is a mild word, abuse...)

2, Calls King of Dewas a pimp or procurer of young boys for E M Forster ( a Passage to India)

3, I thought Maugham's "Razor's edge" was one of the finest novels in English language, he, along with other things calls, it wooden

4, describing Gandhi's ashram, he says there was less of eating and even less of copulating going on there.

There tons more examples.

There was not a single socially redeemable item in the book. So, applying Supreme Courts criteria, I will have to call the book obscene.

Read non-emotional review in NY times.

search.nytimes.com

Here is the first paragraph from the review...

If you wanted to be terrifically shallow, you could just read Jeffery Paine's seemingly scholarly book for the sex. Or the lack thereof. Never was there such an effusion of Protestant guilt and sublimated libido. Gandhi sleeps with a beautiful 19-year-old just to prove he has no more sexual interest in her than her mother did. E. M. Forster turns a maharajah into his procurer. Christopher Isherwood learns he can have a guru and faceless sexual encounters too. There are pedophiles and couples in ''spiritual marriages,'' princes who like dirty jokes and writers who try not to touch another Indian. It's a rogue's gallery of sexual dysfunction, and Paine seems only too happy to dish.

I hope Shashi Tharoor or Salmon Rushdie will review this book.

Regards,
Satish



To: Mohan Marette who wrote (4310)5/22/1999 8:33:00 AM
From: Suresh Havalad  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 12475
 
Mohan

You might be interested in this:
rediff.com

Suresh



To: Mohan Marette who wrote (4310)5/24/1999 9:39:00 AM
From: ratan lal  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 12475
 
Mohan - this is going to be very bad for the country. My understandingis that Pawar has thousands of crores of rupees that he has crookedly amassed and continues to collect more. He is going to use that money to get votes towards prime ministership.

It might be ok if he does make it, but otherwise India will have a prime minister who will now be beholden to even more parties making for 1) total instability and 2) catering to all the crookeds to keep their support. - ratan