Silicon Investor (SI) -- The First Internet Community

STOCKTALK

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor. We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community. If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.

Non-Tech : MB TRADING -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?

To: agent99 who wrote (5052)	7/18/1999 1:09:00 PM
From: -	Read Replies (1) \| Respond to of 7382

Agent99, I've traded with MBT full-time for about 9 months now and have never seen that kind of catostrophic, full service outage occur. They do require you to have a high-quality ISP connection, I don't think a dial-in line would work very well in many cases (depends upon the ISP). But as far as MBT themselves, they have not "gone down and stayed down" in the middle of the day since I've been with them. Terranova's servers have had some occasional, rare "glitches" which last 15-45 minutes, but I've never seen one that stopped me from trading more than a brief time (with MBT, commendably you can call in and both open, and close positions to circumvent the rare brownouts). MBT had a little problem with their routers which was slowing things down, but they've long ago upgraded their network and resolved that. I've heard this sort of thing (the whole brokerage going down, locking out and inflaming customers) reported for ABW a lot of times over the past three years, though. ETrade does it all the time, Schwab sometimes too; for me it is in the "I'm leaving now" department, kind of offense. Of course, the NASDAQ itself (and ISLD) occasionally go down/slow down, but that effects everyone trading, everywhere. A brokerage's transition to a new facility would normally be carefully planned with redundancy, and would normally occur incrementally in tested stages, so as not to risk a full, extended disruption in service. If any brokerage were to pull that on me, I would be questioning their lack of operational planning; it's a red flag that you're not dealing with a fully competent or well managed brokerage team. The thing about ABW is, they have a long history of inflaming their customers with stuff like this. I did a lot of research and this turned up repeatedly. I talked to them and they seemed good enough, etc. but when you go look at the history, it ain't pretty. It goes in waves, the develop big problems, everyone gets mad and leaves, then they make changes/promise to reform, and it improves for a while. That is what spooked me off, I was about to open an account there. I'd still try them if the conditions were right, just an FYI from my brokerage research. I know they brought in a whole new management team to clean it up and take it public, I'd be watching for staying power once they get their act together... -Steve

To: agent99 who wrote (5052)	7/18/1999 2:10:00 PM
From: -	Respond to of 7382

Agent99, Sounds like ABW may be out of the woods for now, as far as lock-outs, please keep us informed. I'm looking to trade the OEX in my IRA account over there! <g> FYI, regarding running RTIII, i run it on a Pentium III setting on a 128Kbps (fractional T1) Frame Relay line and a great ISP www.walltech.com (with a half-dozen other apps running on the same machine); it's virtually glitch-free there. What you may find interesting is, when I travel I run it on a garden-variety Dell Inspirion 3500 laptop dialed in on a 56Kbps analog modem, also with virtually no problems! I find this somewhat amazing myself, and enjoy being able to take the direct-access trading capabilities with me while traveling. Generally on the laptop I keep multiple apps open (besides RTIII) on the laptop (IE 5.0, QCharts, Outlook, etc) and I'm dialed into a garden-variety ISP's local # wherever I'm at (Concentric, CNCX); it all works fine. When I was running CyberTrader, it was much more resource-intensive and finicky about the ISP connection. Frequently crashing, had to close things, etc. So in my experience, RTIII isn't so bad, as far as resource requirements. I suppose a lot depends on how you configure it... -Steve