To: A.J. Mullen who wrote (357 ) 9/10/1999 8:23:00 PM From: Miljenko Zuanic Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 804
AJM: I am not neuro-guy and certainly not qualified to give you professional opinion. However, FWIW, here is my thinking. Attenade will probably have better side effects profile than Ritalin, however this will not be of magnitude (because Ritalin is already good and tolerable drug at mild dose, some more side effects at 20 mg dose) to force DRs and HMOs to subscribe premium priced drug. IF DURATION AND RESPONSE RATE ARE BETTER, STORY IS DIFFERENT. Can you image frustrated parents and kids listening comments during their line-up at school nursing office? Investigators expected (to be honest I was bit suspicious about IMMEDIATE release (+)-R formulation results in PIII, even having in front of me data from CELG patent) that Attenade (at half R dose) will have *comparable results with some IMPROVEMENT*. They didn't expect *statistical significance* for therapeutic effects duration, the most important issue here, imo. After learned for early completion of this trial I immediate drooped my skepticism. Few calls at that time worked very well for me. Methilphenidate (Ritalin) has good bioaveability and fast response (fast and good cns penetration), however it is also metabolized (to ritalinic acid) fast. (+)-Enantiomer is metabolized at slower rate than (-)-one and there are indication that it is ~10 times more potent than (-)-isomers. CELG and other researchers will probably look on this difference (enatiomers versus racemate) in (+)-isomer plasma level and response duration (this will be important for pulse-release formulation). What is known that there is certain trash hold drug plasma level and further increase in dose (over 20 mg) does not increase therapeutic benefit proportionally. Also, many tried in past (and are trying today) to develop extended release formulation with longer single dose drug therapeutic duration. So far, mixed bag, not so good results. So far, it appears that Attenade will break this barrier and for first time be drug of choice for many DRs/kids. Miljenko