To: Jacques Chitte who wrote (56697 ) 10/2/1999 12:13:00 AM From: Michael M Respond to of 108807
L double R -- re. presidential fitness -- expand the list if you wish. The objective of my "restriction" was to insure evaluations were based, at least in part, on direct observation and experience of effect. The wider discussion might be even more interesting but will rely on "hearsay" for foundation. That's fine in some circumstances, esp. debate among scholars who give appropriate weight to many sources. It may be fine HERE. I know more than I want to know about a lot of stuff, and, I revere legitimate scholarship (a bow to Neo, Joan, Edwarda and others), but I am not a scholar and I find the opportunity, if not likelihood, for/of mischief daunting. Example -- I think you're great E, regardless of what we disagree about -- but, if you're going to cite Gary Wills to judge Reagan, you may as well scare up a Hatfield for his views on the McCoys. Back to your reference to HST, IKE and JFK. IMO, Truman was a simpleton -- an honorable, hard-working man -- but, a simpleton. Best move: dropped the bomb. Next best move: integrated the armed forces. Next best move.......? On the other hand, eviscerated the military after WWII -- allowed the Soviets to lock in their position in Europe -- "invited the conflagration in Korea and handled the resulting problem incompetently. For any who might want to test the last assertion, I invite them to find the connection between HST and Mac in WWI. Ike. Honorable man. Not really a soldier (not that he wasn't willing) -- a career HQ kind of guy. Hey, LRR, imagine for a moment, had Ike been the boss in the Pacific and Mac in England..... The next round of "Oh-my-God's" are on me.....Hi Dozo, bitte! By the way, give Ike credit for the interstate system -- HUGE economic benefits. More sentient than The Gipper perhaps -- then again, this was BCNNE! JFK, I mentioned the first time around. Fan of Ian Fleming, Father of the Green Berets and charming rogue. I ramble. Please forgive. Thanks for your provocative comments. Mike