To: Bull RidaH who wrote (33408 ) 11/14/1999 2:09:00 AM From: Casaubon Respond to of 99985
Can someone please provide the counter-argument why options exercises should not be expensed.Go to the SEC Edgar database at www.sec.gov and select Microsoft's 10K report for the year ending 6/30/99 that was filed on 9/28/99. Print off the report, which is 81 pages, and refer to the cash flow statement on printed page 63. On this statement is an item titled "stock option income tax benefits" with the amount of $3.1 billion. What this means in plain English is that Microsoft's employees exercised stock options during 1999 with a value of $9 billion in excess of the exercise price. This amount is included as ordinary W-2 wage income to employees, even though they do not sell the stock, because the tax is triggered on the day employees exercise and take ownership of the stock. This $9 billion in stock option wages to employees also allows the company to take a tax deduction for the same amount or $9 billion since the IRS views this as wage expense. Since Microsoft is in a 35 percent tax bracket, a $9 billion deduction results in a cash flow impact of $3.1 billion. Simply put, Microsoft was able to pay $3.1 billion less in taxes by taking a wage expense deduction that is never charged to earnings. ...It is truly disappointing that Mary Jo did not report any facts so that readers could understand the study without having to link to the web site. Key things like the fact that employees pay tax at ordinary income tax rates when they exercise stock options, even if they do not sell the stock. Even though this is ordinary W-2 income to employees, and Microsoft correspondingly takes a tax deduction as wage expense, this expense is not charged to earnings. Why not say that this amount on which employees paid tax for 1999 was $9 billion and none of it was charged to earnings, even though net income was only $7.8 billion. Of course this is completely independent of the remaining stock option liability of $60 billion. For the full article:billparish.com