To: Ian@SI who wrote (37201 ) 9/9/2000 9:29:45 AM From: James Calladine Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 70976 ANALYSTS AND INFO SOURCES: I agree with you that there are many people in the market who know very little about the companies they hold, and move money in and out of stocks based on the opinions they receive from "analysts" I have developed (for my own purposes), something of a hierarchy about these matters, which goes: LEAST TRUSTWORTHY: The vast majority of brokerage-firm analysts (particularly when talking about specific stocks) and public journalists who talk about such "ratings" and related matters. I view the whole "rating" system as a sophisticated tool for manipulating the market, although, of course it has SOME value. SLIGHTLY MORE TRUSTWORTHY: A few such analysts (who give me the impression that they are striving for a balanced opinion), particularly when they are talking about an entire sector, or portion thereof. This is a difficult call, though, because I have not spent time evaluating analysts to any significant degree. I have to rely on my "bullshit antennna". MORE TRUSTWORTHY: Company financials, press releases and statements of company executives at CC time. (Providing I listen to the Notes to statements, and uncertainties, certainties and so on, of the verbal statements). Some execs strike me as trying to be very straight about what they are saying. Others are just naturally more devious. WHERE I HAVE TO PUT MY TRUST: My own reading of the tea leaves. If I don't have a very solid feeling about everything and understand the time frame in which I am willing to be involved, then I stay away. There are plenty enough good places to be, in my opinion. My own greatest difficulty is in countering my own negative tendencies, which are: -- be too much of a bottom fisher -- be too early buying -- being too fearful of the short term market activity, yet: -- not responding quickly enough to trashings of entire sectors based on very little substance As a result, I continue to try to establish (and keep to) my own ground rules of what I will do and not do. I welcome anybody else's comments on how they wrestle with these matters (if they do!) Best wishes, Jim