SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Strategies & Market Trends : Bob Brinker: Market Savant & Radio Host -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Mr. BSL who wrote (11484)1/6/2001 1:37:03 PM
From: Cautious_Optimist  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 42834
 
Regulators sooner or later are captured by the regulated companies. It is political, not economic determination. The problems come in the transition from regulated to deregulated, which is unfortunately defined by the same foxes in the henhouse.

Utilities and energy companies feel entititled to profits, they should not have to earn them competitively by good service and value. Competition is a better state for the wealth of our society, but the last things these companies want to do is compete, IMO.



To: Mr. BSL who wrote (11484)1/6/2001 2:28:25 PM
From: Boca_PETE  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 42834
 
Mr. BSL - RE: ("The last laugh will be on the consumer")

Great post. Deregulation has killed the golden goose for other formerly legal monopolies. Since deregulation, my phone bill and cable TV bill is way higher than before deregulation. They put so much detail on their bills you can't possibly know what you are being charged for and how it compares to competitors. Just last month Cablevision notified us that the good news was they were not raising the rates for the package we subscribe to, but close examination of the detail advice showed that various other fees were being hiked. What a joke!. Now we get to choose Electrical transmission companies under this deregulation scheme. Prediction - in a few years, bottom line, my electricity bills will be significantly higher. Heaven help us!

P



To: Mr. BSL who wrote (11484)1/6/2001 2:43:54 PM
From: MrGreenJeans  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 42834
 
MrBSL

Regulation works

Deregulation in the energy industry has really been reregulation which is now failing in California because of regulatory pricing that is price caps. Why sell in a price capped California market when you get higher prices out of state?

A utility is granted a monopoly by a state

That is under the old environment. Under the new environment there is plenty of competition and independent generators forming entities. I cite NY.

The utility guarantees CAPACITY

At a price. If a utility does not have capacity they purchase it on the open market and pass on the costs or eat the costs themselves.

The utility’s revenue is cost plus profit.

Cost plus pricing has ceased in this industry for a few years. Utilities have gone to MARKET BASED PRICING. Therefore, retail customers have felt these effects more and more.

The value of electricity never enters into the equation

HORSESH*T! The value of power always enters into the equation and is passed on directly or through surcharges to the end users.

Under this arrangement, the consumer and industry will get as much CHEAP electricity as they will ever need.

In what country is this?

Regulated electricity is cheap because its price never ever approaches market value. What is the market price of electricity? Simply the price that a consumer or business will pay in order to avoid doing without it. We will find out the dollar figure soon enough.

Electric prices have risen substantially in recent years. There have been price spikes during the summer of up to $10,000 a mwh. The market has been and is going to continue to value electric power at market prices. We already know the dollar figure.

A major problem is that outside of price caps energy demand has risen by 12% in certain areas and generation has risen by only 2%.

I have to wonder how in touch you are with this industry at the moment. I could write a few pages on your comments just in disagreement but it is not worth my time.

The Wall St. Journal has focused on the problems in the industry the past few months and have done a good job for those interested.

For the record I work as an energy economist for a major energy firm doing microeconomic pricing and macroeconomic forecasting.