Silicon Investor (SI) -- The First Internet Community

STOCKTALK

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor. We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community. If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.

Politics : Idea Of The Day -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?

To: Al Serrao who wrote (40896)	10/8/2001 1:15:10 PM
From: IQBAL LATIF	Read Replies (1) \| Respond to of 50167

According to the people who knows and news breaking out from Pakistan very influential papers, my part of the world is full of action, very near to my ancestral home town of Sukkur is Pasni, Gawadar opposite to Oman, US C-130's and helicopters are landing and taking off from Pasni, where civilian airport has been taken over by Pakistan Airforce with US AF in the control towers, with US Enterprise 80 miles out in the sea accompanied by destroyers and cruisers where most of the landings and take offs are taking place but lot of Pakistani air bases are under use, it is not only your battle now it is our battle too. Talibans will never forgive us, and we have to win it for our survival.

To: Al Serrao who wrote (40896)	10/8/2001 2:20:42 PM
From: Ira Player	Read Replies (2) \| Respond to of 50167

Al, Your comment "This perception causes many to believe we are a weak and frivolous people who will back down when confronted. How little they know of us and our history." has merit, over the long term. The problem is, the current generation of "evil do'ers" have seen a different side of the USA. We entered Lebanon, were truck bombed and left. The reason Osama bin Ladin and his ilk believe we have no staying power is that is what we have demonstrated. Like the bully on the playground, we were larger, stronger and thought that would cover it. Someone stood up and bloodied our nose and we went home. Desert Storm was the only action we have taken since WWII, where we had effective rules of engagement. If we are to place troops "in harms way", we owe it to them to: 1. Have clear, concise objectives. 2. Authorize commanders to protect any perimeter against attack. This may mean innocents are harmed. If, for example, the truck in Lebanon had contained innocents with a throttle stuck, destroying the vehicle before it crashed into the barracks would have been an unfortunate event. However, not allowing the commander to take action because of the risk of an error is not fair to our troops. If they are sent, they must defend themselves. 3. Aggressively pursue the objective. Collateral damage must be minimized, but the primary objective must be the priority or do not engage. In a military conflict the objective has to be end your opponents ability to harm you. Do not impose external constraints to this objective. My 16 year old daughter and I had a long conversation Sunday morning over breakfast. The first word of the attacks was on the news in the background. She was, appropriately, concerned about the innocents that are being harmed by our actions. She noted that people would be at the airports, in the power plants, etc. and expressed the opinion that we shouldn't be doing it. I asked her what we should do instead, to protect the people in the Sears Tower, or the Congress, or the Pentagon again, or the Mall (had to get a sense of perspective). After some thought, she responded that we have to do it, but we should be careful. I agreed and said I hoped we were being careful and that we should expend some effort to care for the civilian population that was not our enemy. (The food drops had not been announced yet.) She asked if I really thought we would do that and I told her it is the right thing to do, so I'm sure we would. The USA lost the strength you refer to in you comment for a few decades. We showed it again in Desert Storm and then went dormant again for 8 years (sorry, Clintonites, but it's true). It's back now and I hope we never lose site of that strength again. Ira