To: Bilow who wrote (20544 ) 11/21/2001 8:18:20 AM From: Bilow Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 59480 Hi all; Further on the topic of national identity cards (or "driver's licenses". I don't see how state's rights and federalization applies to this. If there were a state that didn't require drivers licenses I can see there being an issue, but the fact is that each state requires drivers licenses. And the states more or less recognize each other's licenses. Since the laws on drivers licenses are more or less uniform (maybe you can get a bit more drunk in one state and keep your license, maybe another state tests you harder when you're old and doddering, but the differences are minor), we should move towards a situation where the licenses are also uniform. It would be more efficient. As far as lost "freedoms", the freedoms were curtailed when the government required the airlines to ask for identity documents in order to fly. I don't think this requirement has stopped any terrorist acts, or made any difference at all to the safety of aircraft. I think this laws was made at the request of the airlines so that they could better control their ticket prices. This may come as a shock to youthful ears, but as a young man I regularly flew using an assumed name. People who collected frequent flier miles would sell tickets, typically through a business, to people who wanted to fly. It made a lot of sense for a "round trip anywhere in the US" frequent flier ticket to be used by, for instance, a traveller from New York to San Francisco than by an inhabitant of Kansas City to anywhere in the US. So these tickets were bought and sold. The airlines, naturally, didn't like this, so they required that the tickets be issued in the name of the person holding the frequent flier miles. That led to a situation where you'd end up flying as "Mary Jones" instead of your real name, which could get kind of odd. In the unlikely event that the airlines noticed this, you had a choice of either claiming to have parents with odd preferences for children's names, having had a recent sex change operation, or that Mary Jones had given you the ticket as a gift. Of course every time a plane crashed the airline wouldn't know who was actually on board... But my point is that the freedom to travel under an assumed name went away when the requirement was made that we show identity documents (usually a driver's license) in order to board aircraft. The nature of those documents, state issued, or federal issued, has nothing to do with the freedom that was taken away. -- Carl