To: ms.smartest.person who wrote (988 ) 11/30/2001 7:28:02 PM From: James Calladine Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 1433 OT: excerpts from a column in today's SF Chronicle re ENE "...Dynegy got in a few extra licks by accusing Enron of "breaches of representations, warranties, covenants and agreements in the merger agreement" -- in other words, lying its Texas tail off. How different from when I was at Enron and the company, the biggest employer in Houston and the largest energy trader in the country, was all but immune to criticism. In fact, that was the first thing that came up when I sat down with Enron Chairman Ken Lay in his plush 50th-floor office, overlooking a new multimillion-dollar tower the company was building and, not far off, the Enron Field baseball stadium. I asked how Lay felt about Gov. Gray Davis characterizing him as a"pirate" who had plundered California's power market. This was back in the darkest days of the state's energy crisis -- remember that? -- when Enron and other energy titans were siphoning off billions of dollars in hyperinflated power charges. "It's very unfair," Lay told me, his brown eyes almost moistening at the very mention of the injustice he and his company had suffered. "He's trying to vilify us. But we didn't make the rules in California. We had nothing to do with creating the problem." Actually, Enron and Lay were early proponents of California's bungled deregulation of the state's electricity market and, according to insiders in Sacramento, played an active role in shaping the legislation that would ultimately be our undoing. Maybe Lay didn't see it that way. Maybe he was in denial. Maybe he just couldn't be bothered to worry about the misfortunes of others when Enron was still on top of the world. That has changed. Enron is now a penny stock and the company's business practices are under investigation. Authorities are looking into murky financial dealings that may have been intended to hide mountains of debt. I can't think of another corporate behemoth that imploded as quickly, or as spectacularly. After my audience with Lay, I was given a tour of Enron's supercharged trading floor. The company's Internet-based bidding system made it the largest e-commerce entity in the world. During the past two years, Enron traders have handled more than $1 trillion in transactions. I had been expecting something Wall Streetish -- men with their ties loosened and sleeves rolled up shouting orders at one another. What I encountered was a vast floor of computer terminals at which sat hundreds of young, casually dressed guys staring calmly into flat-panel displays. There was no yelling. Instead, there was rock music blaring from speakers as traders bopped their heads to the beat and matched buy and sell orders for electricity and natural gas, skimming off a few bucks in profit with each transaction. One trader called up California's power market on his screen. He showed me how Enron was buying electricity at $250 per megawatt hour and selling it at $275. "Some days we're at $250, some days $300 and some days $500," the trader said. To him, these were little more than blips on a radar screen. To California, this was evidence of how badly the state was hemorrhaging money. California now pays about $35 per megawatt hour for electricity, according to the state Department of Water Resources, which is still picking up the pieces from the energy crunch. Things are gradually returning to normal. Enron, by comparison, is staring at the biggest bankruptcy in U.S. history as $61 billion in assets comes up for grabs by creditors. Shareholders, who would be last in line to get their cash back, face the very real prospect of walking away with nothing at all. The damage would be extensive and far-reaching. For example, the California Public Employees' Retirement System, or CalPERS, holds nearly 3 million Enron shares. The stake was valued at $197 million a year ago. It's now worth little more than $1 million. When I was with Lay in his penthouse office, I asked about allegations that Enron had deliberately manipulated California power prices to drive its own profits through the roof. He smiled dismissively. "It's so easy to conjure up conspiracy theories," Lay said. He was right. Easier by the minute." above commentary by David Lazarus 11/30/01sfgate.com .