To: greenspirit who wrote (736 ) 1/26/2002 11:06:00 PM From: Raymond Duray Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 3602 Michael, I don't want to refight the Gilder wars with you here. Suffice it to say, Gilder is a trained economist who has assiduously avoided every economic concept and every financial analysis in his newsletter in order to avoid SEC scrutiny. He's a schemer of the highest order. There's something that is desperately missing from your statement about Gilder's vision of bandwidth plenty. That is economics. The one thing that Gilder was trained in, he avoids discussing like a plague. There's a damn good reason for it. The race to provide bandwidth has created one of the greatest destructions of capital that the world has ever seen. What have we accomplished, exactly? We have a medium, the Internet that derives over a third of its revenues from pornography. One of the most touted growing sectors we find today is online gambling. The most spectaclur bankruptcy in the nation's history is directly tied to the online speculation in energy and other markets by a company that is nicknamed End Run. Perhaps you are aware, or maybe not, that Enron was a key player in the "bandwidth" marketplace. I was shocked to learn last April that of all the trades that had been made for bandwidth between ENE, WCG and the other gunslingers in the previous 18 months that not ONE, repeat, not ONE contract for bandwidth to be delivered as a contract had actually gotten to the delivery stage. In other words, the derivatives market that EnronOnline, Williams and others had created was an utter sham and a complete hoax. There was no there, there. And this is the brave new world that George Gilder hopes to sell to the unwary. Sorry, this isn't a reality we need. Time to get real. And Gilder isn't part of reality. He's part of some pied piper sideshow dream that appeals to folks who may test well, but actually haven't a clue. -Ray