To: Mephisto  who wrote (4531 ) 9/26/2002 6:11:42 PM From: Mephisto     Read Replies (3)  | Respond to    of 5185                       The era of market fundamentalism is over  " Reckless  deregulation in California enabled Enron                                    and other energy companies to gouge customers."                                      iht.com                                      Robert Weissman The Washington Post.                                       Thursday, September 26, 2002                                     Developing countries                                                                         WASHINGTON Marketization, deregulation,                                    privatization and the opportunities for market                                    manipulation offered by inadequate regulation -                                    all central elements in the rise and fall of Enron -                                    are now discredited in the United States. And in                                    developing countries, where their effects have                                    been most devastating, they are the object of                                    widespread public opprobrium. Unfortunately, the                                    IMF and the World Bank continue to sing from the                                    market fundamentalist hymnal.                                     Just as Enron   created new markets in exotic                                    commodities such as bandwidth, so the IMF and                                    the World Bank have worked to marketize services                                    previously in the public and noncommercial                                    realm. Case in point: user fees for primary health                                    care. The World Bank continues to support such                                    charges, even after reversing its support for                                    education fees.                                    The effect is to deny poor people access to care. In                                    Papua New Guinea, for instance, introduction of                                    user fees led to a decline of about 30 percent in                                    the average monthly attendance at outpatient                                    health centers.                                     Reckless   deregulation in California enabled Enron                                    and other energy companies to gouge customers.                                    Similarly, IMF- and World Bank-induced                                    deregulation in developing countries has had                                    disastrous consequences. In the Philippines and                                    in Ghana, for example, deregulation in the mining                                    sector has opened the country to giant                                    multinational companies, displacing tens of                                    thousands of residents and paving the way for                                    environmental devastation. Central to Enron's                                    international agenda was the takeover of                                    privatized electricity and water services in                                    developing countries.  One country where it sought                                    to gain control of a privatized water system was                                    Ghana. Concerns about corruption, including                                    those voiced by the World Bank, led to the                                    collapse of the deal. But the World Bank                                    continues to push for water privatization in the                                    West African nation. In preparation, water prices                                    have doubled, and the bank anticipates prices                                    rising for the foreseeable future, even though poor                                    Ghanaian consumers can pay as much as 10 to 20                                    percent of their income for drinking water. In a                                    country where one-third of urban consumers are                                    not even connected to water pipes, the private                                    operators would have no duty to expand service to                                    the poor.                                    In the Dominican Republic, World                                    Bank-supported privatization let Enron swoop in,                                    buy parts of the electric utility and jack up rates.                                    When consumers and the government could not                                    pay the high prices, Enron turned off the power.                                    Enron and other buyers of the privatized utility                                    are now alleged to have paid too little, thanks to a                                    valuation performed by an Arthur Andersen                                    subsidiary. Enron's financial fraud is now                                    legendary, but consider the IMF's deceit in Brazil.                                     Everyone knows that the country has no prospect                                    of paying off its foreign debt. But rather than                                    acknowledging this and working out a discounted                                    payment arrangement for creditors, the IMF is                                    making new loans to pay off old ones.                                    This has two immediate effects: It enables the                                    private creditors, including the big U.S. banks, to                                    be paid off, with debt obligations shifted to the                                    IMF; and it enables the IMF to extract austerity                                    measures from Brazil that are explicitly intended                                    to lock in fundamentalist market policies, no                                    matter which party Brazilians elect in coming                                    elections.                                    Restraints on corporate power are even more                                    necessary in developing countries than in the                                    United States. But the market fundamentalists at                                    the IMF and the World Bank continue to                                    systematically unshackle corporate activity in the                                    Southern Hemisphere.  That is a major reason why                                    thousands will demonstrate against the IMF and                                    the World Bank in Washington this weekend.                                    Action makes a difference. In 2000, after the last                                    major U.S. demonstrations against the IMF and                                    the World Bank, Congress passed a law requiring                                    the United States to oppose IMF or World Bank                                    loans that include user fees for primary education                                    or health care. Partly as a result, Tanzania lifted                                    primary education user fees, and 1.5 million                                    additional children, mostly girls, were able to go to                                    school.                                     The writer, editor of Multinational Monitor                                    magazine, contributed this to The Washington                                    Post.iht.com