To: kumar who wrote (43626 ) 2/22/2003 3:04:57 AM From: IQBAL LATIF Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 50167 <<Intriguingly some light has been shed upon the vehement opposition towards Valentines Day in the Islamic Crescent and neighbouring nations suhc as India nevertheless there is a discernable trend as evinced by the following articles (1 & 2):>> (Zack continues with his travails..Ike) Silent Observations Intriguingly some light has been shed upon the vehement opposition towards Valentines Day in the Islamic Crescent and neighbouring nations suhc as India nevertheless there is a discernable trend as evinced by the following articles (1 & 2): In India: In the Indian capital, Delhi, several people were reported injured when stores selling romantic cards and gifts were attacked by right-wing militants. An eyewitness told the French news agency AFP: "They came in two cars and began shouting anti-Valentine's Day slogans before entering the shop. "They smashed the glass windows, lights and other fixtures, and tore the cards." "Security has been stepped up across the country to head off violent protests that have occurred in recent years. In the Indian city of Bombay, police will be on full alert to ensure Valentine's Day passes peacefully, a senior police official, Himanshu Roy, told the BBC. "Many hotels in both nations put on Valentine's dinners and balls, while the media allow lovers radio and newspaper slots to broadcast messages. One card stockist in Bombay said couples would celebrate the day despite the protests. Last week, Bal Thackeray said anyone wanting to avoid violence on Valentine's Day should not celebrate it. On Tuesday, 20 Shiv Sena activists stole cards from a shop in central Bombay. Shouting "long live Shiv Sena", they burned the cards on the pavement outside." In Pakistan: In Pakistan, the student wing of the fundamentalist Islamic party Jamaat-e-Islami also called for a ban on Valentine's Day celebrations. Khalid Waqas Chamkani, a leader of the wing in North-West Frontier Province, said: "This is a shameful day. The people in the West are just fulfilling and satisfying their sex thirst." Valentine's is increasingly popular in both nations He condemned "moderate elements" for allowing Western festivities. "They are following the West just to show that they are modern people," Mr Chamkani said in the provincial capital, Peshawar. In Iran: Authorities in Iran have shut stores selling Valentine's Day products and ordered others to remove heart-and-flower decorations. Now of course the protests against Valentine Day celebration is a natural phenomenon amongst radical hardliners who seethe at the onset of Occidental influence in the eastern lands. Nevertheless what is of particular note is the perception and reaction in the BBC press to these separate protests. In India where hardliners "stole" cards (didn't even buy them for God's sake) and burnt them on the pavements of cosmopolitan Bombay implies the growing tide of Hindu fundamentalism. Indeed Bombay (or Mumbai) at the forefront of modern India there had to be protection reserved for those celebrating the holiday of Valentine and security was stepped up. This pales in comparison to Delhi, federal capital of India, where violent protests against the celebration took place and several people were actually injured from anti-Valentine sentiment. Despite this occuring in India, no analysis of the "South Asian region" (whatever that is) would be complete without covering Pakistan. Thus BBC reporters quoted the views of the student leader of the fanatical Islamic party, Jamaat-e-Islami, in the most backward region of Pakistan and propounded as the "anti-Valentine sentiment growing in Pakistan". Indeed the foolish words of Khalid Waqas Chamkani, "Pakistani student leader" (which in itself is a misleading phrase since it amplifies his position), "This is a shameful day. The people in the West are just fulfilling and satisfying their sex thirst", were the accompanying text to the article. Of course one of the articles began with "Religious activists in India and Pakistan have begun separate protests against Valentine's Day celebrations, saying they are an insult to Hinduism and Islam." Now I'm deeply perplexed here dear readers and I do require clarification. How on earth can violent protests and attacks in the sophisticated heart of India equivocate to the words of a forlorn radical in Pakistan's outskirts. These articles indicate the inherent bias against Pakistan and how our good name is sullied by comparison with our rudimentary neighbours. Indeed to go to the trouble of quoting an inhabitant of NWFP is akin to asking a Southerner from the Bible Belt his views on abortion (or Valentine's day for that matter). There is talk of an "I3" alliance, whereby India, Iran and Israel will extend ties to develop the region and thwart rivals (namely Pakistan). To that I can safely say that India, Iran & Israel deserve each other for where else do religious radicals monopolises government institutions as to the extent in these three countries. Pakistan may be ridden with faults nevertheless it is clear that the derogration suffered by tint of being juxtaposed between backward South Asia and fanatical Middle East, compounded by our deep affiliation with Islam, opens us to vilification from the world press. Such a blatant bias is indicative of the daily hostility endured by Pakistan and makes me rethink at times why we sacrifice so much to be the bastion of Western influence in Middle Asia and the rest of the eastern lands. It is indeed a peculiar world when the nation, host to the only thriving and flourishing society of Muslims, is continually denigrated as a "failed state". Nevertheless the BBC articles made me proud to call myself a Pakistani especially considering the extent we've outstripped our neighbours as a nation (which to be brutally frank isn't that much of an accomplishment if one were to consider our neighbours in the first place; theocratic Iran, dependent Afghanistan, peripherial India and of course totalitarian China).latif.blogspot.com Sourced via: Procrastination, "Valentine's Day and Extremists" Zachary Latif 22:40