enough japanese knew japan would lose the war, when they first entered shanghai, before they arrived in pearl harbour
just as enough germans knew russia would be the burial ground of nazi germany, even if england were to fall
war is not won just by force of arms, but by the passage of time and the application of sustained will to win
time is never, ever, with the invaders, because there cannot be sustained will to win
germany and japan would have lost, eventually and naturally, in all cases
they merely expedited the loss cause by having invaded too many nations at the same time
the vietnam war was for national independence, and for freedom from the yoke of colonialism, nothing more, and as no other political system delivered on what the people wanted, communism did, and the people got what they wanted and deserved, but that is another matter - important point is that invaders lost, again
change frame, usa is invading here there and everywhere, now, again, because its people, in the aggregate, want to, nothing more, and will get what is inevitably coming, nothing less
solid ground? so you believe, and that was precisely the sort of muddled thinking that got you into the quagmire and the sand pits ... reflect, ponder, and realize the truth
trillion dollars later
otoh, to think that the japanese invaders and chiang kaishek could have/would have pacified china in concert against the 400 million of have-nots is like believing that iraq could have been paved with roses
<<your own grandfather was Foreign Minister of China, both before and after the Japanese invasion>>
... not quite, his term stopped in 1923.
As to what he thought of the big picture of that time, I am fortunate in that I no longer have to wonder, since some kind soul, out of the clear blue, contacted me this past January and has since forwarded to me the scanned diaries and letters and news articles of grandpa dating from 1938 to 1944. Apparently the kind soul's grandparents were charged with smuggling out the papers from Japanese-occupied Eastern China to Japanese-occupied Singapore. The man himself was left with the papers by his grandmother in 1973 at side of deathbed, but hadn't opened the steamer trunk until 2000, and only recently got hold of my e-mail this past January thanks to Google.
The contents of the papers are brilliant, and as far as predictiveness, <<make the sort of profound judgement that seemingly comes easy>>
Amongst the papers is an open letter written to Chamberlin in 1938 that spec-ed out the alternative scenarios over the coming years, in events and motivations, but not in timing, including all of the big powers, and guess what ... bang on.
BTW, i might add, the natural progression, had japan gotten hold of the bomb first, is that your then primary language would be japanese, and your then japanese-speaking parliament would also debate whether 13 is the right age consent for teenage girls, and instead of coca cola vending machines, your streets would be decorated with machines that sell teenage girls used underwear.
so, going back in time, you have a choice, of enabling the peasant majority to exercising their free will by force of arms, blood sweat and tears, to form a peasant republic that will surely bring on teotwawki in our life time, or a state of is where you speak japanese, and walk past machines that sell soiled teenagers underwear.
so, what kind of man would you have been?
Chiang kaishek chose, fundamentally wrong, and as a result, went against the will of the people, and lost.
You do believe in the power of people power, do you not?
Back on course, in such matters of war, no thanks are necessary, as all are doing self a favor ... do not go the route of the small-mindedness of renaming fried potato as freedom fries, for after all, the French, out of self interest or altruism, did help to bring modern America along, though most of the lifting are necessarily done by the locals. The result would not have been different, only the timing.
In all cases, all around the world, we are always witnessing the actions of people power ... and it is fascinating, always, enlightening at times, useful at other times, and rewarding, occasionally.
Another BTW, some of the scanned letter are on fancy Peninsula Hotel stationary, 10 years after after the Great Depression. It seems grandpa survived the Great 'Recession' and financed his China activities off of income received from his brothers who managed his oil fields in the west indies.
Recommendation: accumulate oil field, hoard gold, ... well, you know, and stay away from revolutions if one can help it |