To: Hippieslayer who wrote (11392 ) 11/18/1997 10:39:00 PM From: Andrew H Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 32384
>> Do you think it is ethical to post something that can not be confirmed without a doubt?<< Well, Fugazi, we certainly can't confirm your opinions without a doubt, but I don't think its unethical to post them. It is entirely ethical to post something that cannot be confirmed without a doubt, since that constitutes about 95% of all posts. It is unethical only if one presents as verified fact that which is not. >>Would you have also been so quick to defend someone else if they had posted that same info yet not have it materialize?<< Probably not, because no one else on this thread has contibuted 1/10 the informational value that Henry has. >>But you and other sure go a long way to defend his every act with out a word of question. That frankly scares me.<< Well, you are easily scared. I am not defending his every act. I am disagreeing with your charactarization and interpretation of his actions.Vehemently so. I think you have trouble distinguishing between fact, information and rumor. But that's your problem. >>Being that he is a professor with ties to LGND, could we not rule out that he would have been floated the journal articles before the publication date. I know they exist.<< You know what exists? What are you talking about? Are you saying you know the journal articles you are accusing Henry of falsely promoting actually exist? >>Your statement of <<He (Henry) communicates it to us in that fashion, so we know it is not a verified act....that often his "information" does not quite mesh with the standards held by a professor.<< Your language here is garbled. I never said "his information does not mesh with the standards held by a professor." That is you speaking. Please don't put your garbage in my mouth. You are again having difficulty distinguishing between fact and rumor. >>If I'm out of line with my points, tell me, but give me good reasons as to why Henry was responsible in posting what he did, not the "Well, he was right about X, therefore we'll believe him on Y"<< You have every right to express your opinion. I would only suggest that since you are in graduate school, you take some time to learn about what constitutes fact and what constitutes everything else. That is all I have to say to you. I will let others who are more interested in your posts respond to you.