To: Chad Barrett who wrote (10017 ) 12/5/1998 10:08:00 AM From: L. D. Read Replies (4) | Respond to of 26850
I'm glad you and John find day trading and TA fun and enjoyable and an occasional comment on a possible price movement is welcome. Nonetheless, kid- like behavior in light of majority's dissatisfaction with a barrage of posts and expert- like comments leaves a lot to be desired. I'm quite positive that you and other day trading souls wouldn't appreciate to see an out of control freak on "Day Trading in Canada" thread bombarding you with the idea that the only way to invest is by adopting Warren Buffet's strategy. Every investment strategy is all right, as long as it works, and it's merits are reflected in the number of digits under "Account Balance", not what one says on SI. Investment strategies are only as good as the person implementing it, what's appropriate for one person might be inappropriate for the other. Judging by some of the post's, one gets the impression at times that momentum trading is THE only way to go. Well maybe so, but if I choose to hold onto my investment as a long- term ( or part of it for that matter ), don't keep on coming back to me and rub it in my face by implying that I'm less of a man than you are. It seems that the "new generation" of day traders feel a sense of duty to visit as many threads as possible and spread "The Gospel" in a similar way as a teenager would do upon loosing his virginity; "Look mom, no hands but I'm still getting an orgasm". The funny thing is, that the most the successful day traders that I've come to meet, never or hardly ever post on SI, and these are the people who would spin me around once, sell me into the market and I probably wouldn't know what has hit me. This particular situation wouldn't get out of control if John would conduct himself in a gentlemanly fashion and, upon reading pleas from some of the participants on this thread, limited the number of posts to acceptable level. Yes, this is a free country and everyone has "The Right" to post on SI, however, no need to get disrespectful and insensitive towards fellow investors. The up- front assumption that one is "The Best" along with his/her strategy and the rest of the crowd out there are just a lost, unsophisticated, aimlessly wandering sheep, speaks volume about the person. It shouldn't be anybody's concern whether or not I'm holding a bunch of "dogs" in my portfolio. I appreciate a different point of view which is presented to me once, it looses the meaning and credibility when it's presented to me ten times in a row. It warms my heart to know that Eric made an impact on you and you recognized some validity in his claim. No doubt he made us stop and think. No doubt he was entertaining at times. Overlooking the above, the fact remains that his malicious accusation didn't make much of a statement about his knowledge and personality. Trust me on this, management wasn't impressed with him at all, which should be understandable as the timing of his theory couldn't be worse, in light of what has happened to the resource market. Any unsubstantiated claim like that places a shadow of doubt on a legit result, which is counterproductive for the company that would like to graduate to a better exchange and before that raise additional WC. Finally, finding the balance between the hype and the reality is our personal choice, it should not be forced upon us. Voicing a point of view is our privilege. But the manner in which it is done is a sign of maturity. I have seen more "Investment Experts" and "Prophets" have their "Star" dimmed in the past two years than I care to remember. Let's not forget that no matter what anybody says, what it comes down to is this: You, your money and knowledge, the machine in front of you and the "Beast" called Stock Market. Good day.