To: Anaxagoras who wrote (1710 ) 1/16/1999 4:08:00 PM From: Anaxagoras Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 4710
Perhaps the following rant is here misplaced; indeed, maybe we need another thread of a more general nature, say "Linguistic Pet Peeves"? The issue revolves around the misuse of 'cynic' and its cognates. The word is not, I repeat not , synonymous with 'pessimist', regardless of what some dictionaries may say. Observe the abuse in the following published piece I just ran across a minute ago (name and title withheld to protect the ignorant, emphases mine):<<In practice many page views still go unsold, perhaps as much as 80 percent or more of the traffic on the Web. Optimists view this as proof that ad revenues have the potential to rocket once the Internet matures as an advertising medium. Cynics view it as proof that the Web ad market is overpriced and subject to crippling price wars.>> Remember that pessimists view the glass as half empty; cynics (in the modern sense) see it and wonder what the guy who placed it there was trying to get out of the deal. Maybe a tip? The former finds its gloomy childhood personification in A. A. Milne's depressed donkey; the latter is that college freshman you may have met, armed with a little learning, who thinks that human actions are motivated exclusively by self interest. Indulging in a bit of mind reading, I suspect that part of the confusion lies in the fact that neither cynics nor pessimists usually make for cheerful company, and I doubt an optimist would knowingly invite them out for a drink. But misanthropes also don't make for merry gatherings, and yet you seldom find an optimist misusing the word 'misanthropic'.<g> Unfortunately, it happens that sceptics are also frequently mislabeled. Sigh.... Anaxagoras