To: Douglas V. Fant who wrote (38545 ) 3/1/1999 8:29:00 AM From: Platter Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 95453
NICOSIA, March 1 (Reuters) - Saudi Arabian Oil Minister Ali al-Naimi on Monday cast doubt on the wisdom of any fresh output cut pledges to revive low prices in view of OPEC's poor history of supply restraint. Naimi also told the Middle East Economic Survey that Iran had to comply fully with existing promised production cuts before OPEC could consider doing more to boost glutted markets. His remarks indicated that a months-long dispute with Iran over supply cuts had still to be resolved before the producer club can erase a global glut. Naimi said in an interview with the weekly newsletter that he had no doubt a further OPEC production cut of two million barrels per day (bpd) would raise prices for a few months but no-one knew how long its effect would last. "There is also the problem as to whether those concerned will actually implement such a cut. There is a track record here, and it is not a very good one," he said. "One thing we need to accept is the sanctity of agreements," he said. Naimi added that the dispute over the volume of cuts Iran was meant to have made under an OPEC agreement last year concerned all its 10 signatories, not just Saudi Arabia. "The issue is not one of Saudi Arabia versus Iran," he said in an an interview with the weekly. "Nine countries are asking the 10th (Iran) to live up to the June 1998 accord." "It is an issue of compliance with agreements, regardless as to what each one of us thinks or does not think. We worked out an agreement. A reference base has been decided. This is the question," he said. OPEC meets in Vienna on March 23 to decide output policy in an oil market where prices are running at 22-year lows in real terms despite 2.6 million barrels per day (bpd) of cuts agreed by the cartel last year. Iran insists OPEC should recognise its right to cut supply from 3.925 million barrels a day rather than the 3.623 million bpd used as a a baseline last March when OPEC first decided to reduce supply. Iran and Saudi Arabia have held talks aimed at aligning their positions but Iran says any compromise had to come from Saudi Arabia. Naimi said further steps could be considered if OPEC could demonstrate to the market that it had adehered to its promises of supply restraint. But he added: "We cannot do it just by calling for more cuts. Who believes us? Who is going to cut? That is the biggest question: who will cut?" Naimi said that the masterminds of last year's output cuts -- Saudi, Mexico and Venezuela -- were working to align their views ahead of any meeting between the trio before OPEC's March 23 gathering. "Whenever we decide to meet expectations rise. We must therefore have extremely good preparations for meetings. There have to be consultations to ensure that there is sufficient common ground for a meeting. That is what is going on right now," he said. Concerning Venezuela, Saudi Arabia's other traditional OPEC rival, Naimi said he was encouraged. "The new government is saying: 'We will comply... I believe them." Naimi rejected Iraqi calls for a cut in Saudi supply by over one million bpd to make up for the expansion in its supply during Iraq's absence from the market under U.N. sanctions. He said that $18-$20 a barrel for U.S. WTI crude would be a "reasonable price" for oil. Naimi said that the main problem facing oil producers was weak demand rather than excess supply. Naimi was not concerned about supply from non-OPEC producers.