To: Hawaii60 who wrote (7216 ) 5/5/1999 12:49:00 AM From: Plan B Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 30916
OK Hawaii, but here's another article from the same site which echoes my concerns:soundingboardmag.com In particular, this quote: "Right now, VoIP doesn't buy you much," argues Steve Hensley, vice president of engineering, GST Telecommunications Inc. (www.gstcorp.com). Largely that's because VoIP makes the most business sense as a way to gain rate arbitrage on high international calling rates. "That's where it makes most sense today, "notes Richard Shimizu, marketing director, Electric Lightwave Inc. (www.eli.net). "Costs are pretty low already for domestic long distance, so I don't see a lot of domestic IP voice traffic, at least [not]today." Also this re quality: "VoIP technological immaturity remains a factor, though most agree the wrinkles will be ironed out over the next several years. "The bottom line is that if you want to serve the business segment, you have to pay a lot of attention to quality," Elliott says. And, so far, packet delay (latency), packet loss (dropped packets) and other speech degradations remain key issues." Also from the article you quoted, (http://www.soundingboardmag.com/articles/951feat3.html) this statement I find rather poignant: "If you start from the perspective of standard voice service, IP telephony isn't comparable at this point," Dym notes. "But if you're coming from the perspective of adding voice to text chat or e-mail, it looks pretty cool." That points out what I said earlier that N2P is not quite ready for prime time. Furthermore it emphasizes the "gimmicky" nature of N2P. Now that's not to say that that alone doesn't have value. I just think we all ought to understand just exactly what VOIP and N2P is at this moment. This is why N2P is being spun off, it fits with the rest of the emerging net ideas like chat, ICQ, and so forth. It's difficult to predict what IDT will be after the spin off but certainly they will have to do more infrastructure building and partnering to be ready for the day when VoIP is prime time.