SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Pastimes
IS CANADA A FREELOADING NATION?
An SI Board Since November 2002
Posts SubjectMarks Bans
27 0 0
Emcee:  Mr. Forthright Type:  Unmoderated
Pat Buchanan called Canada a freeloading nation. As a Canadian I say: HE IS RIGHT.

What do YOU think?


<<Buchanan calls Canada 'freeloading nation'

Canadian Press

Toronto — Canada is a "whining" country that has been "freeloading" off the U.S. defence budget for decades, outspoken American talk-show host Pat Buchanan said Friday.

The latest attack to come from the failed Republican presidential candidate followed his televised comment that Canada is a "Soviet Canuckistan" because Canadian officials objected to a U.S. law demanding photos and fingerprints from Arab-Canadian visitors to the country.

"Post 9-11, we've been making a tremendous effort to try to secure the American people," Buchanan said in a telephone interview from Washington, D.C., where he co-hosts a daily talk show.

"And to hear this kind of carping criticism from north of the border, from folks whom we give a $50-billion (U.S.) trade surplus each year and whom we defend while they have been in some ways freeloading off the United States, got a little bit into my craw."

"We exercise occasionally the right to criticize [Canada] and what I hear from up in Canada is some juvenile whining."

On Tuesday, Foreign Affairs Minister Bill Graham issued a warning to Canadians born in Iraq, Iran, Libya, Sudan and Syria highlighting a U.S. law that targets foreign visitors originally from those countries.

Two days later, however, Mr. Graham said U.S. ambassador Paul Cellucci had assured him that everyone carrying Canadian passports will receive identical treatment at border crossings, no matter where they were born.

While Mr. Buchanan called Canada a "safe haven for terrorists" and said Prime Minister Jean Chrétien had done an "appalling" job of securing the country's borders, he also said U.S. President George W. Bush has not done enough to counteract terrorism in his own backyard.

If Canadians don't want to visit the U.S. because they object to being fingerprinted and photographed, that's their prerogative, Mr. Buchanan said.

"As it's their prerogative to criticize this country and ours to do likewise."

Mr. Buchanan's comments were first aired on the MSNBC show Buchanan and Press on Thursday. Almost half a million people tune in for two hours daily to watch Mr. Buchanan, a notoriously conservative former Ronald Reagan and Richard Nixon speechwriter, face off with the more liberal Bill Press.

Despite Mr. Buchanan's wide audience, his comments don't represent the way most Americans think, said Maude Barlow, spokeswoman for the Council of Canadians.

"[His comments aren't] fair to most Americans because most Americans don't think the way Pat Buchanan does," Ms. Barlow said from Ottawa.

"But if you don't know anything about Canada and this is all you're seeing, it can spread a pretty viscous lie."

"He's using Canada as an excuse here to whip up racist sentiment in the Untied States, but what people need to start talking about right now is how to get along."

This week wasn't the first time Mr. Buchanan has given Canada a verbal lashing.

In 1990, Mr. Buchanan wrote that if Canada shattered following the failure of the Meech Lake constitutional accord, "America would pick up the pieces."

Two years later, he said: "For most Americans, Canada is sort of like a case of latent arthritis. We really don't think about it, unless it acts up." >>
Previous 25 | Next 25 | View Recent | Post Message
Go to reply# or date (mm/dd/yy):
ReplyMessage PreviewFromRecsPosted
27Taliban to target Canadian civilians Group says slaying of aid workers was act average joe-8/19/2008
26Getting rid of the past if U'r wonderingLaFayette555-4/6/2006
25New Low -- Canada to U.S.: Mind your business Don't tell us how to run our mCage Rattler-11/22/2002
24Canada has made its mark in history as a champion of peace and democracy. We oweaverage joe-11/14/2002
23How about the old snap election threat? I'm outta here he that happens.Mr. Forthright-11/10/2002
22Why don't you change the thread name to "Escape from Canada" and waverage joe-11/6/2002
21I wonder if it is fair to conclude that B.C. and Quebec might be isolated anti-ACage Rattler-11/4/2002
20I live near the US/Canadian border, and have had contact with US citizens that hNeeka-11/4/2002
19I've postponed travel to the US because #1 the US is under attack and #2 becLaFayette555-11/4/2002
18Just as we have postponed all travel to Canada. Just don't think we would bNeeka-11/4/2002
17LOLMr. Forthright-11/3/2002
16Agreed, this is only lip service from the US, or may be the'll strip search LaFayette555-11/3/2002
15I'll bet you anything the US has not changed its new rules. It may have giveMr. Forthright-11/3/2002
14Amazing, even the Globe and Mail has gathered enough courage to be critical of oMr. Forthright-11/3/2002
13RE: " Mr. Graham said U.S. ambassador Paul Cellucci had assured him that evLaFayette555-11/3/2002
12cagle.slate.msn.com cagle.slate.msn.comX Y Zebra-11/3/2002
11Yeah well... I would have done that already... except that I don't speak QuX Y Zebra-11/3/2002
10corrigan.ca Bye4Now, FD.Bicycle-11/3/2002
9If you are going to complain about the cold air then i want to file an official Mr. Forthright-11/3/2002
8There seems to be a lot of Canadians on SI, maybe this thread will give them a fMr. Forthright-11/3/2002
7Tazio can run but he cannot hide...average joe-11/3/2002
6of course I did not. unlike the average joes of the world, I am not looking forX Y Zebra-11/3/2002
5Did you see this? medicirc.orgaverage joe-11/3/2002
4you forgot to blame yourselves for the cold weather, particularly in the summer.X Y Zebra-11/3/2002
3We are a nation of MOOCHES and looky-lews....average joe-11/2/2002
Previous 25 | Next 25 | View Recent | Post Message
Go to reply# or date (mm/dd/yy):