To: Dayuhan who wrote (11442 ) 4/15/2001 11:17:28 PM From: E Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 82486 That story makes me tremble. It makes me feel sick. If a child of mine was involved in it, she would never forget what followed. I would do all I could to make her and every girl involved understand the depth of shame I felt in her behalf and that she should feel. Why it would take a lot of self-examination and remorse and seeking of forgiveness to begin to set things right. I think they should beg for forgiveness on their knees. I think the parents of those girls should beg the victim child and her parents for forgiveness on their knees. It makes me so angry that I wouldn't trust myself to handle the situation. I sure hope you tell Joey that if he ever hears of anything so horrible going on again, he should tell you immediately. I think there should be deep classroom and weekend discussion with the children, especially those girls, of the phenomena of bullying, scapegoating, and social sadism. I think the participating girls should be asked to write essays telling exactly how it made them feel to be sadistic bullies, and to write reports on their opinions, line by line or idea by idea, to studies they are assigned on these subjects. I think they need to see what they did as behavior on a spectrum with other evil behaviors. I think the participant girls should be asked to volunteer, one at a time, to be shunned for a week. It won't be the same, but it might show them a little something, and it might help the victim child to see it happen to others and to be offered the opportunity to be kind, if she wanted to, as no one was kind to her. I suddenly remember something I haven't thought of in years. When my sister's son was a young boy, my sister found out that he and a group of his friends had been taunting with anti-semitic slogans the old Jewish shopkeeper of the little local deli/grocery store -- a survivor of one of the well known concentration camps, a man with numbers tattooed on his arm. My almost hysterical emotional reaction to this story you've just told brought back what happened to my sister. When she heard it, she went sort of berserk with shame and horror and grief. She grabbed her son, she was crying, she dragged him to the store, she told him as they ran there what a concentration camp was, what that man had lived through, how terribly cruel what the boy had participated in was. She took him in and, weeping, apologized to the man, explained that her son didn't know what he was saying, saying how ashamed she was of the boy's behavior. I'm sure my nephew learned something from his mother's shame and apologies. (And he's a wonderful fellow today.) I'm sure no book would say my sister did the right thing, adults aren't supposed to lose control, and it's true she's a bit nutty, but... in a way, such a direct emotional reaction may not be so wrong. If my child had been involved in that school episode, I would think a profound apology on my part, public, in front of my child, to both her parent and to her, would be an appropriate lesson. Oh, that poor little girl. But I'm so freaked out by the story that I'm not sure of my judgement.