SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : War -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: LV who wrote (3197)9/6/2001 12:32:43 PM
From: GUSTAVE JAEGER  Read Replies (5) | Respond to of 23908
 
Re: The Jews, the Kurds, the Tutsis of the world, those who have often been the target of abuse or worse, they all have learned bitter lessons what it means to be defenseless. And the only way to defend oneself is to have one's own country and army. Since Jews were minority everywhere, they had to congregate together in one place, and Israel is the only place to which Jews are historically connected. I know you find the effects unpalatable and you disagree with the entire concept, but I hope you can understand....

Yes, as far as I can grasp the "herd mindset", I can understand you indeed... I mean, sometimes I said to myself, "How would I feel about that whole Middle East mess if I were Jewish?" and my answer obviously is: "Heck, I'd just stick by my fellow Israelis --thick and thin, right or wrong..."

Now, let's get real for a minute... You claim that "the only way to defend oneself is to have one's own country and army" and therewith you hint at the United States and its history of war and conquest at the expense of Native tribes --fine. But remember, LV, that, from the outset (in 1777), the self-proclaimed United States of America were self-reliant, so much so to successfully carry through their independence from Britain. The newly sovereign United States didn't rely on some alien power to prop up its precarious regime (pace Lafayette and the French), nor did it need massive inflows of money to sustain a permanent war economy... (rather the opposite, see the Louisiana purchase for example) Hence, don't fool yourselves: you Jews haven't forwarded your self-sufficiency by an inch! Somehow, you are still as powerless as your forefathers, still a frail minority eager to become the protege of the Earth's overlord... Just as in Europe's ghettoes of yore, when benevolent princes and barons granted you safeness. And, likewise, when your American "sugar daddy" will switch plans as the whim takes him, your leeway will be brought up once again...

Gus.



To: LV who wrote (3197)9/9/2001 5:30:23 PM
From: Mani1  Read Replies (4) | Respond to of 23908
 
Re <<And then we learned of the real world>>

I can't say that I am aware of all the evil that is happening in this world, but for my age, I have been around the globe. This world is more "fair" than it was 2000 years ago and there is no reason for the trend to stop this century.

Re <<The Jews, the Kurds, the Tutsis of the world, those who have often been the target of abuse or worse, they all have learned bitter lessons what it means to be defenseless. And the only way to defend oneself is to have one’s own country and army>>

See, that is just it. If Jews are entitled to their own country because they have been target of hatred and atrocities, then why shouldn't every body else? Almost all races and ethnicities have been target of unfair practices (granted not to the extent of the Jews) but starting to divide the earth based on religion or race, and sacrificing the very same rights of another race or religion is not the solution.

Re <<I know you find the effects unpalatable and you disagree with the entire concept, but I hope you can understand.>>

Yes I disagree with the concept and more so its side effects. My Parents are Iranians. I am not proud or ashamed to be Iranian. I could care less. I am who I am and my genetic ancestor do not make me a good or bad person. My genetics does not entitle me to any special right or obligate me to make up for any of their mistakes. As I have mentioned on this thread before (I think), I am involved in the "Big Brother" program in San Diego and my little bother happens to be Jewish. I will give my life to make sure that such atrocities will not happen to him, but I will do so because he is a human which I care for, not because he is Jewish.

It really bothers me when I read the comments on this thread and realize how most of us have lost the big picture. We are differentiating ourselves based on BS reason to the point of dehumanizing other religion or races. And we are justifying our action on what happened decades or centuries ago. And worse yet, we are teaching our hateful practices to our children so the killing can continue.

Mani