To: Mad2 who wrote (15823 ) 9/12/2001 10:06:57 AM From: RockyBalboa Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 18998 Mad2, interesting to see what discussion developed. But there are some small disturbing things in the way how GWB treats the tragedy (besides that he appearently continued with his presentation at the school for 1/2 hour after having been informed - which is simply inexcusable): "All supporters of the terrorists must be punished." While I believe that what he intended to say is that he seeks to apply "radical treatment" of a cancer including the nucleus, which is in general a good thing (at least if you really manage to extinguish all roots), even some European leaders warned of an escalation multiplying the losses. It would be impractical to highly questionable to punish all supporters: -the grocer who sold good to the terrorists, -the bank at which they maintained accounts, -the (civilian?) airliner who trained pilots turned terrorists, or supplied manuals? -the mad arabian kids who don't know what they did in celebrating the tragedy... The last time collective guilt was the reason was for racial cleansing in Serbia, and before, in Hitler Germany when Jews have been murdered only for their confession, Socialists have been terminated for their political opinion, and again after the world war when many innocent germans have been murderer only because of their presence in central European countries. What did Hitler say after one of the assaults directed against him? -make a list of suspects -kill them all If revenge, and only revenge is the preferred means and good excuse at the same time, then good night, and god bless, the world won't. Sadly enough, there is no way to undo the tragedies at the WTC and the Pentagon (and revenge is not the way either).