To: QwikSand who wrote (45393 ) 9/20/2001 1:42:25 AM From: Nick Kline Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 64865 I'm not shocked that we didn't know about this ahead of time. It's just very easy to do this kind of thing in a free society. They even had a black market that functioned somewhat in communist Russia. That's not saying that we shouldn't try to prevent terrorists, or do everything we can to catch them (I hope I didn't need to say that). But who knew ahead of time about Timothy McVeigh, or the first bombing of the world trade center, or any number of the biggest terrorist events? When we had huge domestic surveillance in the 50s, 60s, and 70s, we didn't know someone was going to kill JFK, or MLK, or John Kennedy. We didn't know that people were going to bomb school houses with children in them, we didn't know who was killing civil rights workers in the 60s. We did know some things about the FBI's political enemies such as that MLK had affairs (and I suppose we knew about JFK's too). It's important for the government to have good intelligence, but its naive to believe that omnipresent federal surveillance will give us complete protection. This is a delicate and complicated thing, the federal government's police power. We have to be very careful that this power is not abused. There are many examples where the FBI's intelligence lead to lots of arrests of criminals, but it also had lots of down sides too. I'm one person who is hoping that we slow down before we lose too many civil rights, rights that will be hard to recover once they are taken away. I've already read articles (in the wsj) reporting on suggestions that we pass new laws allowing deporting of people from other countries without due process, and escrow key registration has raised its silly head again (its too late now, and it was too late 10 years ago). Hey, a Sun point - does that famous encryption guy still work at Sun, was his name Whitfield Diffie (or maybe that is two last names put together). I'm totally in favor of a strong defense, but as the too much quoted phrase of Ben Franklin says, you shouldn't be too eager to give away your rights for some sense of freedom. -nick