To: Neocon who wrote (3299 ) 11/25/2002 10:39:04 AM From: Ilaine Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 6901 It's hard for me to tell whether Michael Moore knows that he is being intellectually dishonest but does it anyway, for effect or because it suits his purposes, or whether he just can't think clearly enough to realize he's doing it. At any rate, he does it often enough that it's a predictable character flaw. One of the things I thought was very dishonest about Bowling for Columbine was the way that he handled the issue of race. He definitely suggested that Americans are racist for thinking that blacks commit a disproportionate number of violent crimes -- which may well be true, but doesn't disprove the fact that blacks DO commit a disproportionate number of violent crimes -- as do Hispanics. My own guess as to why blacks and Hispanics have such a high murder rate in the US has to do with expectations. Moving from New Orleans, a place of low expectations, to Fairfax, a place of high expectations, was an eye opener. Of course, the population of Fairfax is whiter, richer, and better educated, so how do I know that expectations make a difference? When Rudy Giulani became mayor of New York, he proved that high expectations can make a big difference - the so-called "broken windows" theory. I think people have a tendency to get away with as much as they can. In places where they are allowed a lot of latitude, they will misbehave far worse than in places where bad behavior isn't tolerated. I have only been to Canada once, drove from VA to Halifax to watch an eclipse, spent time in both New Brunswick and Nova Scotia. The social norms seem to tend more towards order, e.g., not much trash in the streets, drivers stop when they see pedestrians in the crosswalk, not much in the way of rowdiness around the port bars in Halifax. Compare and contrast with, say, the South Bronx or Southeast DC.