SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Pastimes : My House -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Lazarus_Long who wrote (5947)3/12/2003 11:10:25 PM
From: Solon  Read Replies (7) | Respond to of 7689
 
"The question is simply this"

Thank you. An abstract question is different than one which relies on verifying premises in actuality.

"Is the neighbor justified?"

The neighbour will always say he was! But WAS there a violation? WAS there a threat? What kind of a threat? Says who? What kind of military action was taken? Was it genocide? Was it blowing up a dam? yada yada

As I said...I am not going to spend this evening researching the myriad details of 1935, 38, 42, or any other year. I am trying to write a program for a roulette strategy.

""Christianity has the authority to control the behaviour of all adherents.""

Such interpretations no longer fly in our culture.

"Which Islam? THere's more than one sect, just as with Christianity"

Islam has every right to force all sects to the "Book".

"And hardly all predominantly-Muslim nations are theocracies"

FREE individuals do not exist under ISLAM. Free choice does not exist. ALL right or wrong is listed in a book. What shoes you wear...what hand you wipe your bum with. You summit to the divine will as it is written...PERIOD.

It is one thing to talk about papal infallibility and the atrocities committed back then. It is another to misunderstand the essential differences here. The Islamic "duty" relates to a cultural striving for cultural power.

Of course all Muslim Nations strive for theocracy and have it when they truly predominate. Islam Nations do not allow any other religions...PERIOD. America was able to control Turkey with the military with lavish money and worldly support. But with the new Government it has become more dificult, hasn't it? Likewise, they have pandered to Saudi Arabia because it is not only wealthy, but the Islamic center of Holiness.

"That is the only way to safety if what you say is true"

I don't believe that is the way to safety. I believe it is allowing the joys of secularism and human rights and freedoms under law in order that superstition and madness from old books is forgotten. The political/social reason for religion is equality and power. When people are given some self sufficiency and power they are no longer attracted to whatever virgins are promised them in the grave. Allow people to enjoy virgins and fresh water and fresh fruit here and now!

"Against religious fanaticism? Useless. It doesn't even work against secular states like Cuba"

It HAS been working. As for Cuba...it is unique. In spite what you may have heard...many Cubans love and admire Castro. I give the old bastard credit.