To: NOW who wrote (10176 ) 8/4/2004 5:25:55 PM From: mishedlo Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 116555 Bear Stearns argues no housing bubble.... Note: The following is in reply to a PM I received stating that Bear Stearns says there is no housing bubble and that we are in the early stages of expansion.... Mish Reply: I do not think we are in the early stages of an expansion. I think we are in the 8th inning of an expansion and down by 5 runs. The US never stopped expanding IMO. Ok for one quarter big deal. I also think Greenspan gets one more hike in and he is done. I do not think the market can take any more. 2 more 25 bps if he is lucky. Europe is a disaster and the only growth engine in the world is the US. That is not sustainable. Too much debt, too little stimulus left, and rising energy prices and health care costs are taking a toll. You are correct about one thing, however. The homebuilders are not building too much on spec. I got into an argument with someone on my board over it. However that lack of supply based on just in time, does not mean supply is not coming. In some cities and Orange county CA, houses went from 30 day supply to 3.5 month supply. That is a huge change. There is probably a lot of property tied up with the intention of building houses that just do not get built. Depending on homebuilder leverage to land, homebuilders may or may not be in deep sh*t. It may vary homebuilder to homebuilder. However, we do not need to see homebuilders crash or even housing prices to collapse to cause our economy to collapse. This whole deck of cards is 100% dependent on keeping the US consumer spending, and keeping housing going. Paul Kasriel at Northern Trust did an interesting column on Housing Collateral damage. He is 100% correct. Look at all the mortgage jobs, real estate jobs, trade jobs, trucking jobs, concrete pouring jobs, asphalt jobs, lumber mill jobs, home depot jobs, curtain making jobs, carpeting jobs, etc etc etc that are all dependent on housing. House PRICES are not necessarily the most important factor. In fact, I believe housing related jobs and the income they provide are far more important than home prices themselves. It only takes a hombuilding slump to knock out a huge huge chunk of the US economy. Perhaps everone is looking the wrong way or for the wrong thing. Perhaps home prices just do a slow sink and not a collapse. It's the loss in housing and housing jobs that is carrying this economy. The home refi boom is over. If prices just stay stagnant it is not coming back. If they decline it will kill home equity loans as well. Roughly 70% of people here own a house now. How many more are left when you consider huge numbers of people in cities like LA, Chicago, NY, Boston etc just do not want to own or are just plain not candidates to own. Who else is left to buy, in the face of rising interest rates? Where are the marginal buyers coming from now? Do you think we keep expanding if homebuilding slumps? I think it is IMPOSSIBLE if homebuilding slumps. Now personally, I think some areas housing prices will crash, but more than likely you are correct about prices slowing coming down. People are missing the big picture IMO looking for this housing crash, it is a HOUSING JOB CRASH not a housing price crash that everyone should be fearing the most. Some areas of the country will probably get both. The home refi bubble collapsed and that is taking its toll on consumer spending. Those tailwinds are gone and now we have the headwinds of 1-2 more rate hikes, corporate tax credits ending, job grown barely keeping up with population growth (if it really is at all), real declining wages, and rising energy prices, and a stock market that seems to have topped out. How much longer can a house building boom last? What are the implications when it stalls. The stock prices of homebuilders is not relevant except as an indicator of some kind. The prices of homes is relevant, but not as important as the jobs themselves. Is house building in the early stages, the 8th inning as I suggested, or is it really the bottom of the 9th? Mish