To: engineer who wrote (16942 ) 10/23/1998 2:55:00 AM From: Rajala Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 152472
>My "friend" Q did NOT say that singalling was the problem. >You have said this more than 3 times now and still you have nothing >to back it up. There is no signalling. You have had 3 responses as >to how it works. It is NOT signalling, this never changes. It is >still one bit every 20 ms frame of 192 bits (if you cared to read >the standard). What changes is the statistics of the channel and >the ability of DSP software loops to track the power control. >A better estimatation allows the power control loops to track >closer, thus providing the best estimate of the channel and >getting another 3 dB out of the users by allowing more to the >stacked as addtitive white noise in the channel. Also there is >less probability that users will all suddenly move around, thus >requireing more handoff channel reserve channels. I have always wondered, engineer, whether you wear one of those funny engineer hats when you write your postings. I think we should be told. OK so you say there is no signalling problem. Then you say you save 2/3 of the capcity by not having more accurate power control and by not having to deal with handoffs. Well, power control and handoff are signalling. If I read your last sentence above correctly (which is difficult since it appears to make no sense whatsoever) you are trying to prove some capacity advantage on saved signalling. Anyways, my point is this: WLL is useless concept, because it offers insignificant savings over CDMA1 and CDMA1 is far superior a proposal. >I do not know what your "CDMA1" tehcnology is, since it is not what >has been proposed by anyone. Is this CDMAOne, CDMA2000, IS-95A, >IS-95C, WCDMA, BCDMA? Please enumerate on this so that I can >understand if this is the difference in our communications? No wonder you have had hard time understanding my postings. >..yet you rant on with such authority. Please present your >articles and MBA's reports so that we can all read them. I have no authority. There's no need to present articles and MBA's reports since they are all for WLL. I think WLL concept is a dog. - rajala