To: Knighty Tin who wrote (100169 ) 2/16/1999 11:07:00 AM From: BGR Respond to of 176387
MB, Let me try to address a few points here: 1. Price: If DELL is grossly overpriced by any particular pricing model, then the S&P500 is obscenely overpriced by the same. Now, this may mean to you that the entire market is due for a fall, but even in that case DELL should fall less than the market at large. Hence, DELL is a superior investment to the S&P500 (which, BTW, 80%+ of mutual fund managers failed to beat in '98). 2. The reason, perhaps, is DELL, which is slowly wiping out competition. It is hard to imagine that continued well-being of it's competitors would be considered a pre-requisite for DELL's success. DELL continues to enjoy extremely strong YoY revenue, EPS, unit and market share growth. 3. It is your guess against MD's, and pardon me for saying this, MD probably has better credentials (in particular since you have displayed reluctance to use statistical models in your analysis). 4. The channel is DELL's competitotr, which it is slowly wiping out. Therefore failure of the channel points to DELL's success, not failure. I do agree that SP500 earnings are a concern. However, my personal experience tells me that since human resources is infinitely more expensive than h/w, h/w budget cuts are relatively slower to come. Also, in this age, whoever is not investing in technology is a sitting duck and CFOs know that - so priorities have changed. But I acknowledge that this is a good point. 5. This doesn't apply to DELL. This is primarily a product of the lower end swampland of sub 1k and soon to be sub500 PCs. DELL has been smart enough to avoid this segment and continues to display it's acumen. 6. Like you, I do not care about option related sells as well. 7. True, but that is such a general statement! This is true for every single technology company in the business which started in the last decade. 8. Excellent point, as DELL's model is not the best to handle component price inflation. I posed this question in this thread back in nov '98. It will be interesting to see how DELL handles the situation. 9. DELL avoided the swampland on purpose. It is a great strategic success! It doesn't need to increase units while sacrificing margins. 10. DELl has one of the best management team in the business today, a world class SCM implementation and a fabulous procurement, manufacturing and distribution system. -BGR.