SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Non-Tech
Analysts who are really, really bad
An SI Board Since March 1998
Posts SubjectMarks Bans
25 4 0
Emcee:  Trey McAtee Type:  Unmoderated
well, i think we all know the frustration of having some boneheaded analyst make comments swinging a stock in a direction opposite the one we want it to go. this is a group to vent about these morons, and the power they weild with the lemmings.

first on my list is DAN NILES of BA/Robertson Stephens, and TOM KURLAK of Merrill Lynch.

these guys are some of the worst in the semi industry. Kurlak, who is widely considered to be the semi ax on wall st. is one of the brilliant people who thought the outlook for Micron Tech was GREAT last summer. of course, those of us on the MU only thread saw through his rather ignorant and superficial pimping of the stock.

of course, Niles is an idiot in his own league. even Kurlak doesnt have the kind of brass balls this guy has. i think he STILL has a buy rating on MU, which makes me wonder...exactly what does he have on his boss? i mean, if i messed up as bad as this guy does, my clients would run away from me so quick they would make the roadrunner look like a grandmother with a walking frame.

THEN today, on CNBC (well known for its acurate stories and hard hitting questions<G>) this moron from Piper Jaffray was on talking about INTCs problems. oh, what hilarity. his name is Ashok Kumar, and the next time he is one TV anywhere, please let me know. analysts are supposed to KNOW little things like, oh....i dont know... the name of PRODUCTS that company's they track ship. Ashok, if you're listening, its CELERON, not covington that is INTCs new P2 for sub1k computers. also, you might want to check with the company, but they arent integrating cache into the bottom line version. maybe you should actually try working instead of just regurgitating dataquest reports.

well, thats about it for my vent thus far...but i am sure tommorow will provide much to talk about.

good luck to all,
trey
 Previous 25 | Next 25 | View Recent | Post Message
Go to reply# or date (mm/dd/yy):
ReplyMessage PreviewFromRecsPosted
25Gee, not much traffic here... Guess all the analysts are really, really good. George the Greek-8/24/2000
24 I nominate Ed Snyder as idiot of the year. His calls regarding Qualcomm have cJGoren-6/27/2000
23 I found a site that gives analyst returns. I'll have to dig it up again. Wayners-5/22/2000
22 BTW, I definitely think that, in terms of holding their feet to the fire, analyGeorge the Greek-4/6/2000
21 I just knew this was a thread whose time had come. I was going to start it todaGeorge the Greek-4/6/2000
20 Trey, I have never kept track of the analysts myself, but I have often seen thR. Gordon-4/21/1998
19 r.-- hey, i love the idea. my goal in starting this was to create a place wherTrey McAtee-4/20/1998
18 Trey and All, My interest in finding this thread was because I have been ongoiR. Gordon-4/20/1998
17 thomas ROTFLMAO. i love the wordy one. negativity? oh pish. thats nothing. wTrey McAtee-4/13/1998
16 Trey, yeah. Outside of this one and "Analyst Bashing (orcl intc mu amat csThomas G. Busillo-4/11/1998
15 thomas-- i will check it out again. cramer isnt a bad guy, its just the mania Trey McAtee-4/10/1998
14 Trey, even if Cramer isn't your taste (I happen to like the guy), the rest Thomas G. Busillo-4/10/1998
13 thomas-- i dont read the street, mostly because i think james cramer is some kTrey McAtee-4/9/1998
12 Trey, I'm VERY excited to see thestreet.com's rationale for declaring DThomas G. Busillo-4/9/1998
11 thomas-- this is the problem with axes...they suck! niles doesnt want to be a Trey McAtee-4/8/1998
10 Trey, Dan Niles strikes again. Is it me, or does Niles have a strange tendency Thomas G. Busillo-4/8/1998
9 thomas--- one can always count on old dan to make a call. even if hes wrong, aTrey McAtee-3/23/1998
8 Trey, hey, how about that Dan Niles <g> The guy upgrades MU to a long-teThomas G. Busillo-3/22/1998
7 brian-- i am not familiar with her, but there are some good analysts, one of wTrey McAtee-3/9/1998
6 brian-- amen. the klauer woman i am not familiar with, but as you know burlap Trey McAtee-3/9/1998
5 Re:<i>Anybody know a good analysts</i> I'm not sure if her titProud_Infidel-3/7/1998
4 Anybody know a good analysts?Larry G.-3/7/1998
3 This thread has been a long time coming....if most of these guys were paid on aProud_Infidel-3/7/1998
2 goblins-- i think they probably cover their tracks pretty well. other than mayTrey McAtee-3/6/1998
1 Great idea for a board. I cast my vote for any Merrill Lynch analyst. VERS, ESOgoblins-3/6/1998
 Previous 25 | Next 25 | View Recent | Post Message
Go to reply# or date (mm/dd/yy):