Who's Guiltier?-- Andrea Yates or her Husband?

STOCKTALK

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor. We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community. If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.

Pastimes
Who's Guiltier?-- Andrea Yates or her Husband?

An SI Board Since February 2002

Posts	SubjectMarks	Bans
74	4	0

Emcee: Ann Corrigan	Type: Unmoderated

Introduction Compact

Go to reply# or date (mm/dd/yy):

Reply	Message Preview	From	Recs	Posted
24	Not "shift the blame to"....rather just hold him at least responsible	Ann Corrigan	-	2/26/2002
23	Coincidentally, I was watching the news last night and there is a guy here in Ca	Jorj X Mckie	-	2/26/2002
22	Yes, I have 2 children. Not sure how that relates to the discussion? I know r	Ann Corrigan	-	2/26/2002
21	Is that the answer then when an insane person commits murder? In fact, the reas	Ann Corrigan	-	2/26/2002
20	<i>A clever lawyer could probably convince a jury of the responsibility on	Jorj X Mckie	-	2/26/2002
19	Do we know this is something he forced on her?? Pregnancy can be equally t	Ann Corrigan	-	2/26/2002
18	If he caught her in the act or about to commit the act & could not in other	Ann Corrigan	-	2/26/2002
17	They are both guilty, she however should suffer the same fate as those kids.....	jjetstream	-	2/26/2002
16	They should take it easy on her....should put a nice cushion on the electric cha	Gut Trader	-	2/26/2002
15	If the Husband killed her to premptively prevent the act; is he innocent of murd	Gut Trader	-	2/26/2002
14	I would lockup the Psychiatrist treating her in a Turkish Prison. If she were t	Gut Trader	-	2/26/2002
13	I agree with your questioning these things. <i>What evidence do you have	Neenny	-	2/25/2002
12	I think your conclusion is irrational. Without knowing the day to day life in	Neenny	-	2/25/2002
11	I was talking of the "insanity" part. Whether hormonal or not. I am q	Jorj X Mckie	-	2/25/2002
10	that assumes that he knew the ramifications of enlarging the family. How do you	Jorj X Mckie	-	2/25/2002
9	I have not followed the information on the case that closely to know if "en	Neenny	-	2/25/2002
8	He would not have suffered postpartum depression. It's a hormonal imbalance	Ann Corrigan	-	2/25/2002
7	Usually the law is lenient when a person is insane. Assuming he is sane, would	Ann Corrigan	-	2/25/2002
6	I would agree with this. My wife had pretty severe PP depression. I took a mont	Jorj X Mckie	-	2/25/2002
5	Clearly I would say she is guiltier. She was the one that killed the children.	Neenny	-	2/25/2002
4	It's disappointing that the american public is fixated on her guilt without	Ann Corrigan	-	2/25/2002
3	I think that it was irresponsible and should weigh heavily on his soul. But, I d	Jorj X Mckie	-	2/25/2002
2	Yes, Jorj. If she mothered 2 additional children with him even though a psychia	Ann Corrigan	-	2/25/2002
1	If he had killed the children instead of her, would you be looking to shift the	Jorj X Mckie	-	2/25/2002

Go to reply# or date (mm/dd/yy):